Benjamin Franklin’s thoughts on war

Published February 5, 2003

PHILADELPHIA: When fears of a devastating attack by French and Spanish privateers swept Philadelphia in 1747, Benjamin Franklin circumvented the city’s pacifist Quaker leadership and organized a private army of 10,000 defenders.

But if Franklin were alive today, would he be among the national chorus of pundits baying for a US war with Iraq?

Probably not, says Yale University historian Edmund Morgan, a leading authority on the 18th century printer, inventor and statesmen who helped secure America’s independence through diplomacy and the weight of his international reputation as a genius of the Enlightenment.

Morgan believes Franklin’s highly reasoned views about world affairs could be useful to 21st century US policy makers at a time when the prospects for war with Baghdad are straining relations with allies including France and Germany.

A philosopher who believed people capable of moral perfection, Franklin saw war as a hazard to be guarded against like fire or lightning.

“He’s a citizen of the world, maybe the first in modern times,” said Morgan, 87, who is Sterling professor of history emeritus at Yale and administrative board chairman of the university’s archive of Franklin’s papers.

‘BETTER WAYS’: “He had no scruples against war. But he thought it was too expensive a way to accomplish what wars are generally intended to accomplish, whether in terms of territory or ideology,” added the professor, who is author of a best-selling biography “Benjamin Franklin” published late last year.

“There were lots of better ways of doing things.”

For example, when war broke out between Britain and her American colonies in the 1770s, Franklin proposed ending the hostilities by having the United States purchase England’s North American possessions including Canada, Bermuda and the Bahamas.

“If we are to obtain them by conquest, after perhaps a long war, they will probably cost us more,” he wrote in 1776.

The proposal went nowhere, and Franklin joined the Revolutionary War effort.

What little direct military experience he had was limited to defensive militias organised in times of dire emergency.

Today, Franklin’s popular image is one of a kindly old gentleman who published his own guide to the good life in Poor Richard’s Almanac and proved lightning to be a form of electricity by flying his proverbial kite in a thunderstorm.

But Franklin was also a subtle diplomat who, as the first US ambassador to France, believed good government thrives mainly through the good opinion it enjoys among its citizens and allies. In fact, Morgan argues that America might not have won France’s support for the revolution, if the French had not held Franklin himself in high esteem. And there could be no independence without France.

“Now we’re on a course that could lose us the good opinion of our allies and the consequence of that is something we can’t even imagine,” said Morgan, who opposes US President George W. Bush’s policies on Iraq. “Franklin thought there was no such thing as a good war or a bad peace. If you’re thinking about how that reflects on the present day, it’s pretty obvious.”—Reuters

Opinion

Broken promises

Broken promises

Perhaps the biggest impediment to the successful mainstreaming of ex-Fata and its development has been the lack of funding.

Editorial

Wake-up call
09 Nov, 2024

Wake-up call

THE United Nations Human Rights Committee has sent a clear message to the government: it must work to bring the...
Foreign banks’ exit
09 Nov, 2024

Foreign banks’ exit

WHY are foreign banks leaving Pakistan? In the last couple of decades, we have seen a number of global banking...
Kurram protest
09 Nov, 2024

Kurram protest

FED up with the state’s apathy towards their plight, the people of Kurram tribal district took to the streets on...
IHK resolution
Updated 08 Nov, 2024

IHK resolution

If the BJP administration were to listen to Kashmiris, it could pave the way for the resumption of the political process in IHK.
Climate realities
08 Nov, 2024

Climate realities

THE Air Quality Index in Lahore once again shot past the 1,000-level mark on Wednesday morning, registering at an...
Rule by fear
08 Nov, 2024

Rule by fear

THE abduction of an opposition MNA, as claimed by PTI, is yet another grim episode in Pakistan’s ongoing crisis of...