MUMBAI, Dec 4: India’s intelligence agencies have descended into “civil war” following the Mumbai attacks that exposed the country’s vulnerability to terrorism, analysts and experts say.

The country’s various security bodies have long refused to communicate and now blame each other for failing to act on information that could have thwarted the terror strikes, they said.

A week after the attacks, and amid mounting public anger, reports are emerging that intelligence agencies knew that India’s financial capital may be targeted by extremists.

India has more than a dozen intelligence agencies that decline to pool information or answer to a central command, said Wilson John, senior fellow at the Observer Research Foundation think tank in New Delhi. The agencies range from the National Security Council Secretariat, headed by a political appointee answerable to the prime minister, down to the military and police.

John said their “reluctance, and even refusal, to share information” that could prevent attacks “sends a message to terrorists that they can breach Indian security, that they can come in here and do anything”. “Ultimately the buck stops nowhere,” he added.

Mumbai is the hub of India’s western naval command and situated near offshore oil rigs and the country’s nuclear installations, he said. “I keep asking who was heading the operation to flush out the terrorists. There was not a single man in charge,” he said.

“The police, paramilitary personnel, firefighters, the coastguard, all were operating in isolation. There was no one in charge which is why 10 guys were able to hold off hundreds of men deployed from the security forces.”

Newspapers said the government’s external intelligence unit, the Research and Analysis Wing, intercepted phone calls as recently as November 18 about plans for assaults on Mumbai hotels.

The calls specifically referred to the luxury Taj Mahal hotel, one of last week’s targets, but the information was not disseminated, the Hindustan Times said.

India’s approach to intelligence was comparable with that in the US before the “9/11” attacks, said a foreign intelligence specialist, referring to the lack of coordination among Washington’s internal and external

agencies. —AFP

Opinion

Editorial

A hasty retreat
Updated 28 Nov, 2024

A hasty retreat

Govt should not extend its campaign of violence against PTI and its leaders, thinking it now has the upper hand. Enough is enough.
Lebanon truce
28 Nov, 2024

Lebanon truce

WILL it hold? That is the question many in the Middle East and beyond will be asking after a 60-day ceasefire ...
MDR anomaly removed
28 Nov, 2024

MDR anomaly removed

THE State Bank’s decision to remove its minimum deposit rate requirement for conventional banks on deposits from...
Islamabad march
Updated 27 Nov, 2024

Islamabad march

WITH emotions running high, chaos closes in. As these words were being written, rumours and speculation were all...
Policing the internet
27 Nov, 2024

Policing the internet

IT is chilling to witness how Pakistan — a nation that embraced the freedoms of modern democracy, and the tech ...
Correcting sports priorities
27 Nov, 2024

Correcting sports priorities

IT has been a lingering battle that has cast a shadow over sports in Pakistan: who are the national sports...