Sir, war is avoidable. Mullah muhamad umar is respnsible for it. US had just askd for Osma. Many religous teachers also advised OBL to leave the country but Mullah was adamant and claimed OBL was a guest of the country. Large number of innocent Afghans have been killed and so Have Nato troops. Now Mullah claims that when all foreign troops leave the country, no civil war like nineties will take place. Peace will prevail and Karzai can continue to rule. Mullah is not sincere in his negotiations with US with sincerity fearing that US might withdraw even before 2014 to prevent further bloodshed. As regards prisoners in Guantanamo, the issue can be discussed separately and resolved and should not be a stumbling block towards peace. I feel sorry for Afghans who have suffered since 1979.

I am not sure which world r.s.soni lives in. Mullah Umar is not responsible for the war it is the US. When Taliban asked for evidence against OBL so that he can be tried in Afghanistan, why did the US not provide that evidence. If it was the other way round US would have insisted on getting the evidence to try the culprit in the US, why could US not accept an international law. Mullah Umar is a resident of Afghanistan, US and NATO are the invaders, in the same way the Russia invaded Afghanistan. Mullah Umar fought against the Russians with the full support of US. Why is it that when you kill a Russian soldier, you are called the Mujahadene (by the US) but when you kill a western soldier for the same reason (liberating your country from the occupiers), you are called a terrorist. I don't support the Taliban but US is by far the bigger terroist in the world, responsible for far more deaths than Taliban.

The US gave them no proof of Bin Laden's involvement. The discussions over handing over OBL never really happened as the US had already started sounding the trumpets of war. They should have had some form of dialogue with the Taliban back then. I can't see how the US will completely out before 2014. I don't see it happening. The problem was and still is the US's war mongering attitude.