Conservation: No heritage, no identity

Shah Masjid Chitral: Restoration or destruction. — Photo Siraj Ul Mulk
A person without memory has no identity, likewise people without heritage. Over the course of 30 years, living and travelling in what was once called North-West Frontier Province (now Khyber Pakhtunkhwa), I have seen a number of wonderful heritage sites — Buddhist remains in Swat, wonderful fort and museum at Shabqadar, the old British colonial Munda bridge in Abazai, the fabulous mosques in Kohistan and Dir, the mosque and fort in Chitral, the Kalash defence towers in Jinjeret Ku plus the archaeological wonders of Peshawar.
Unfortunately, they are now all at risk. Concerned citizens are doing their best to preserve these sites, whether through press-releases, newspaper articles, press conferences or litigation. For example, recently FHT along with Citizens for Clean Environment became involved in a law suit against destroying the green belts of Peshawar such as in front of Islamia College.
This also pertains to the great mosque in Spin Jumaat, where a red line for demolition is clear to all.
A couple of weeks back, we were informed that the historic Khyber Pass would become the new highway from Afghanistan through Pakistan to Central Asia. Anyone who knows the Khyber Pass, knows that it is full of historical sites, such as the tunnels of the railway, which was built at the beginning of the last century; there are cliffs with the insignias of various regiments that served in the area, there is also a fort at Mitchener’s Point. To build a modern highway engineered by the National Highway Authority (NHA) there leaves one incredulous.
A couple of weeks ago, I was astounded to receive an email with an attachment photo of Shahi Masjid, Chitral, with a huge hole below its minaret, caused, believe it or not, by dynamite — all in the name of restoration. As usual, no one accepts the blame for this sacrilege and as usual the local administration turns a blind eye.
In Chitral, professionals had been asked for their expertise for the restoration of Shahi Masjid and an enormous sum of money was quoted. This has resulted in the dynamite debacle. Is this expertise?
What does it take to preserve heritage?
Some years ago I met up with an old friend, Adil Zareef, whom I had not seen for a long time. The meeting took place at the Mughal Bridge Peshawar. Sarhad Conservation Network (SCN) of which Adil was a member, was celebrating restoring an old pillar of the bridge which had lain on the grass for many years. A few years after this SCN and Frontier Heritage Trust took a stay order against the demolition of Muhafiz Khana. The interior of Muhafiz Khana was overflowing with historical records all to do with Excise and Taxation Depatment. The old colonial building, with its high ceilings and long fans was maintained by a few lowly baboos, whose dress seemed to be as old as the colonial period.
Take, for example, the defence/watch towers in Jinjeret Ku, the only ones remaining in the Kalash valleys (Jinjeret Ku was Kalash till 1920s and the people there still speak Kalasha language). A conversation with the right person did wonders. The right person in this case was the Finnish charge d’affairs. She willingly donated money for their restoration. On the completion of the project she came to the valley to inaugurate their opening. She was brave enough to climb the very difficult wooden steps.
In 2011, with the cooperation of various people and groups such as SCN, we accessed the Vintage Car Club to find specialists for restoring the two antique fire engines in the old fire house in Gor Khuttree. With our know-how and the keenness of the then Secretary of Culture, Azam Khan, we presented a PC-1 to the Provincial Government, which then donated the funds.
One of the things that I have noticed in the preservation of such things is the keenness and pleasure of the people engaged. All of us, involved with the restoration of the fire engines, including the museum people, thoroughly enjoyed the venture. And, we were not the only ones. When we transported the fire engines from their place of temporary residence to Gor Khuttree, all shining with bright new red paint, people along the way stood transfixed. One gentleman nearly got run over trying to photograph us! When we reached the Old City, we were followed by numerous children.
In other words, enthusiasm, determination, awareness and cooperation between groups and people can help save our heritage.
Perhaps, all the historical sites, in what is now KPK, should first be examined by various civil society groups, who carry the enthusiasm and determination to preserve the history of this province.
The other factor is that when development takes place in Peshawar, such as the recent construction of flyovers (many more to be built), so much of our green belt is destroyed along with historic buildings. Recently, the Chief Justice of Peshawar High Court declared that it was illegal to cut down even one tree, and the perpetrators would be punished as if they cut down the whole forest.
Every day I receive emails from friends and acquaintances who have come across some new horror regarding development and destruction of some precious buildings or parks or green belts.
Civil society hopes that the Provincial Government will take notice of this horrific plan for Gor Khuttree, the dynamiting of Shahi Masjid in Chitral and the destruction of the green belt and trees in Peshawar. For city dwellers the green belt and the trees are a necessity and keeping them safe should be done with ‘religious’ zeal.









Enthusiasm,determination,awareness and cooperation between groups and people can help save our heritage
Those who have re-written in text books for their new generations to read have no face to go and protect the ‘heritage’. History have proved this again and again that those who have ignored their roots have ceased to exist after a while.
Europe has preserved its heritage since many centuries (even since thousands of years). The interesting thing which i have noticed is that they visit these sites because they love their heritage and secondly to spend few euros there to finance the maintenance of such sites. I hope one day we will have such a love for our heritage and pass this love to our future generation.
with the speed of well-planned destruction, there wont be any ‘heritage’ left by the middle of this century.
“A person without memory has no identity.” Really??? I need not bother myself with the rest of the poetry. Conservation or not your write up ironically does start off as discriminatory against people with dementia.
Having lost an Uncle to dementia, I find the starting comment (no matter what you think you mean by it) too ironic to read past it.
Learn from India. They protect their Mughal and Vedic Heritage. When will the people of Pakistan learn to accept that. When ??
First step is to acknowledge the history and culture. As long as one tries to find identity in a foreign land S.Arabia, nothing is going to apppen.
Very True .
Very appropriately, the writer speaks that a person without heritage has no identity. The sense of identity, pride and self-respect is fading away in our society. One cannot always rely on authorities especially when at present they are ineffective. The role of civil society is commendable and they need all our support. There could be several ways to revitalise the spirit of identity through heritage sites. However, immediately for the masses education, all sites and building’s significance requires a write-up for public display. For instance, Muhafiz Khana for an ordinary man is only an ancient building dangerous to live in. If there is a written history right outside the building for the general public’s education, they will be keen and enthusiastic enough to raise their voice and show disgust if anyone damages the site.
I also believe that in the past many buildings were destroyed purposely regardless of their historic significance. Falaksair Cinema in saddar is one such example. All facts must be published periodically in all the languages spoken in Peshawar. All officials and parties who were involved in demolition have to be named. This include the Judge, Controller of Military Land, Executive Officer of the Cantonment board, Station Commander, Garrison Commander and last but not the least the politician who later acquired the land for the new plaza. Every detail has to be accurate and full of facts so no one denies the truth.
Name and Shame them.
A question must be asked regardless of their background. Ask them to prove that they are not related to the ancestors who used to hang from their tails of the banana tree’s branches. Ask them to point out evidence and not to become mere storytellers.
Everyone will make sure that they are not from the Ape family and have a respectable identity.
And Hindus are accused of Babri Incident everyday
Until recently,muslim civic society had never complained against the destruction of hundreds of hindu temples in the last thousand years, and also in the last sixty five years.
muslim civic society ?? ha ha ha … marvelous joke……..
My sentiment are same. Well said