Court calls for laws before troop pullout

Published September 18, 2013
The KP government had announced phased withdrawal of troops from the Malakand division, including Swat, last week.   — File Photo by AFP
The KP government had announced phased withdrawal of troops from the Malakand division, including Swat, last week. — File Photo by AFP

PESHAWAR: The Peshawar High Court directed the federal and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa governments on Tuesday to make laws before withdrawal of troops from Malakand division so that different issues, including the future of hundreds of suspects detained in the region’s internment centres, could be given legal cover.

“No decision shall be made in a haphazard manner as withdrawal of troops without proper legislation will result in legal and constitutional crises,” said a two-judge bench comprising Chief Justice Dost Mohammad Khan and Justice Nisar Hussain.

The court issued the directive during the hearing of about 250 habeas corpus petitions of “enforced disappearances”. The KP government had announced phased withdrawal of troops from the Malakand division, including Swat, last week.

The bench said if the troops were withdrawn without any legal cover, the court would be flooded with hundreds of petitions by internees who would be seeking their release because apparently they would be in illegal detention then. These internees could not be transferred to other prisons because they had been held under a special law and, therefore, legislation was needed to provide a mechanism for their shifting to regular prisons, it added.

The court asked KP Advocate General Abdul Lateef Yousafzai and Deputy Attorney General Muzamil Khan to consult the government, the attorney general, Judge Advocate General Branch of the Army, the federal law ministry and the provincial law department to find a way out of the impasse.

The advocate general and the DAG informed the court that the withdrawal would take place in three phases.

The bench told the two law officers representing the centre and the province to consult the authorities concerned about the legal consequences of withdrawal since the notification issued by the prime minister calling troops in aid of civil power was still in the field. Other questions that need to be addressed are maintenance of internment centres, transfer of detainees to regular prisons and their future course of trial and the pattern and mode of trial requiring legislative cover. The provincial and federal government, as well as the military’s legal branch, should sort out these issues, it said.

“Legislation shall be made with extreme care, but with reasonable speed, before withdrawal of troops as desired by the provincial government so as to avoid constitutional and legal crises,” the bench said.

The advocate general and the DAG said they had held a brief meeting with the officials concerned but sought more time to take up the matter with the federal and provincial governments, the attorney general and JAG branch of the army.

Chief Justice Dost Mohammad said it appeared that the federal and provincial governments were not on the same page on the issue. A comprehensive framework should be made keeping in view all aspects of the matter.

He said the Action (in aid of civil power) Regulation 2011 was under challenge in the high court, but keeping in view the ground realities it delayed the matter to provide a breathing space to the authorities.

Opinion

Editorial

Out of control
Updated 19 Feb, 2025

Out of control

AS bodies continue to fall in Kurram despite a state-sanctioned ceasefire, one wonders how long local militants’...
Hollow words
19 Feb, 2025

Hollow words

IT is not uncommon for politicians to resort to the use of hyperbole in order to boost their public standing. ...
Migration matters
19 Feb, 2025

Migration matters

THE grass, it seems, did appear greener on the other side to millions of people as evidenced by the latest UN ...
Cholistan project
Updated 18 Feb, 2025

Cholistan project

GPI goals align with Pakistan's broader economic aims but the manner in which the initiative was launched raises questions.
Right to know
18 Feb, 2025

Right to know

IT is an unfortunate paradox that while on paper Pakistan has some of the most impressive right to information laws,...
Dam dispute
18 Feb, 2025

Dam dispute

THE situation in Chilas needs attention and a fair-minded approach so that it can be resolved amicably. Diamer ...