Germans deny dance mocking Argentina racist

Published July 17, 2014
(LtoR) Germany's national players Roman Weidenfeller, Shkodran Mustafi, Andre Schürrle, Miroslav Klose, Mario Götze and Toni Kroos perform a so called "Gaucho dance". -Photo by AFP
(LtoR) Germany's national players Roman Weidenfeller, Shkodran Mustafi, Andre Schürrle, Miroslav Klose, Mario Götze and Toni Kroos perform a so called "Gaucho dance". -Photo by AFP

BERLIN: Commentators chided Germany's football champions Wednesday for mocking Argentina during a giant World Cup title party in Berlin, an event that marked a rare exuberant celebration of national pride.

In a country where strident patriotism is still largely taboo, newspapers said the young players' “tasteless” victory dance on Tuesday reflected badly on Germany.

Six of the players including Mario Goetze, the sole scorer during Sunday's 1-0 win over Argentina, performed a taunt often seen in stadium stands, on a stage set up behind the capital's Brandenburg Gate before hundreds of thousands of flag-waving fans.

“This is how the gauchos (Argentines) walk, the gauchos walk like this,“ they sang, mocking the South Americans as a hunched-over, short and little people, to cheers from the crowd

Then they jumped up and chanted, “This is how the Germans walk, the Germans walk like this!” and strutted around the stage.

The word “gaucho” is the South American equivalent of “cowboy”.

Several German newspapers called the display of swagger before the world's media a sour note after an otherwise pitch-perfect World Cup.

“The victory celebration at the Brandenburg Gate turned into a gigantic own-goal,” the conservative daily Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung fumed.

“With a mean satire of the opponents in the final, the German world champions are squandering the image of an open-minded, tolerant nation. “


'Tasteless'


Berlin's centre-left Tagesspiegel called the display “tasteless” and said it overshadowed the team's gracious behaviour on the pitch in Brazil.

“The German modesty is over. Their joy wasn't enough, they only find full satisfaction when they torture their mourning vanquished opponents a little, “it said.

“Maybe that is what will remain in the heads of many people outside Germany from this World Cup. And then the frenetic applause of the audience. They didn't mean anything by it, that is probably true. But they showed that in football there are not only fools but damned fools. “The criticism sparked a lively debate on Twitter under the hashtag #gauchogate, with many attacking what they saw as political correctness run amok.

A user with the handle @suburp said, “Germany has a word for #schadenfreude but struggles w fun and healthy national pride. It's only FUSSBALL (football). regt euch ab. (Calm down).“

Die Welt newspaper said the dance did not mark a “shining moment” but added: “We don't need to overplay it.“

A senior member of the opposition Greens, Juergen Trittin, agreed the dance had been “unsporting” but said the backlash was an overreaction.

“I wouldn't give it greater political significance,” he said.

“Let's not jump to conclusions that it was about nationalism. That is not what is reflected in opinion polls. “

Trittin said Germans were proud of their winning football team “but have also learnt from their own horrible history”.

As the issue gathered steam online, the head of the German Football Federation (DFB), Wolfgang Niersbach, said he regretted any hard feelings.

“We are sorry if anyone took this the wrong way,” he said in a statement.

Niersbach said he would write his Argentine counterpart Julio Grondona “to make clear again that this action was in no way meant to be disrespectful”.

“We have great respect for Argentina, the best relations with the local federation and look forward to seeing each other again at the match in Dusseldorf,” referring to the national teams' next game against each other on September 3.

He said the dance had arisen “spontaneously from the emotion and joy" around Germany's fourth World Cup title.

“They are all absolutely decent and fair sportsmen who wouldn't make fun of anyone and just wanted to party with the fans,” Niersbach said.

Opinion

Editorial

Haniyeh’s murder
Updated 01 Aug, 2024

Haniyeh’s murder

The Israelis are playing with fire, and their brinkmanship can push the entire region into a catastrophic maelstrom.
Unjust measures
01 Aug, 2024

Unjust measures

IS it a justified move or a needless provocation? Days after the Supreme Court’s order in the reserved seats case...
Equitable taxation
01 Aug, 2024

Equitable taxation

HERE are two key takeaways from Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb’s speech at a business gathering in Karachi on...
Extremism unbound
Updated 31 Jul, 2024

Extremism unbound

Unless those who actually control the levers of state act with alacrity, the forces of darkness may be further emboldened.
SBP’s rate cut
31 Jul, 2024

SBP’s rate cut

THE second consecutive rate cut by the SBP underscores the fact that the central bank is relatively bullish on a...
Mountain feats
31 Jul, 2024

Mountain feats

THERE has been a flurry of activity and new records set on the summit of the ‘savage mountain’ this summer. On...