THIS is apropos of Zubeida Mustafa’s article, ‘Language can unite’ (June 15). A metallurgist by profession, I am no linguist. But I see how fashionable it is within British elites to embellish English by throwing some French expressions (like tete-a-tete, chauffeur, fait accompli, etc).

Similarly, we Indians do embellish our Hindi by throwing in some Urdu words, sometimes wrongly.

Thanks to great singers like Ghulam Ali, Mehdi Hassan, Jagjit Singh and Pankaj Udhas, I fell in love with Urdu ghazal and started listening to the genre.

The biggest problem was that it always seemed as if I understood the verses when I actually didn’t. Then I started listening to the verses with a dictionary in Devnagri script in my hands, and I suddenly realised the reason behind my confusion.

I think many verbs in Urdu owe their origins to Sanskrit (e.g. khaana, peena, karna, bharna, aana, jaana, etc.) So the expression ‘pyaar karna (Sanskrit — to love) is a mixture of Urdu (‘pyaar’ in Hindi is ‘prem’) and Hindi karna (Sanskrit).

When I heard the line ‘Fareb-e-tabassum mein phir aa gaye hum’, it sounded familiar but fareb and tabassum were unknown till I looked it up in the dictionary.

Even today in India where Urdu is only one of our official languages, we seem to unconsciously use a lot of Urdu words, particularly on TV where equivalent Sanskrit words are available.

As a person from Maharashtra, I never knew what ‘haseen’ meant. Even words like ‘husn’, ‘qurbaani’, etc., were unfamiliar to me, but not anymore.

Thanks to a dictionary by a professor (the late Zarina Sani) and a dentist (Dr Vinay Waikar) from Nagpur, we now have ‘Aaina-e-Ghazal’, a dictionary of Urdu-Marathi-Hindi-English in Devnagri script.

K.B. KALE United States

Opinion

Editorial

Back in parliament
Updated 27 Jul, 2024

Back in parliament

It is ECP's responsibility to set right all the wrongs it committed in the Feb 8 general elections.
Brutal crime
27 Jul, 2024

Brutal crime

No effort has been made to even sensitise police to the gravity of crime involving sexual assaults, let alone train them to properly probe such cases.
Upholding rights
27 Jul, 2024

Upholding rights

Sanctity of rights bodies, such as the HRCP, should be inviolable in a civilised environment.
Judicial constraints
Updated 26 Jul, 2024

Judicial constraints

The fact that it is being prescribed by the legislature will be questioned, given the political context.
Macabre spectacle
26 Jul, 2024

Macabre spectacle

Israel knows that regardless of the party that wins the presidency, America’s ‘ironclad’ support for its genocidal endeavours will continue.