Judge rejects release of info given to makers of Bin Laden movie

Published September 5, 2013
This undated publicity photo released by Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc. shows Director/Producer, Kathryn Bigelow, left, and Writer/Producer, Mark Boal, on the set of Columbia Pictures’ thriller, “Zero Dark Thirty. – AP Photo
This undated publicity photo released by Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc. shows Director/Producer, Kathryn Bigelow, left, and Writer/Producer, Mark Boal, on the set of Columbia Pictures’ thriller, “Zero Dark Thirty. – AP Photo

WASHINGTON: A US judge has refused to allow the public release of information divulged by the CIA to the producers of the film “Zero Dark Thirty,” a judicial source told AFP on Wednesday.

The Hollywood movie about the hunt for 9/11 mastermind terrorist Osama bin Laden relied on information disclosed to its director Katherine Bigelow and the movie's screenwriter Mark Boal by the US Central Intelligence Agency.

The names of key figures involved in the planning of the top secret mission were sought by the non-governmental group Judicial Watch, which had argued in a court filing that since they had been revealed by US intelligence, they no longer could be classified as secret.

Judicial Watch in its suit in US District Court criticised the Barack Obama administration, which it said “gave the Hollywood filmmakers unusual access to classified intelligence information, including the names of CIA operatives involved in the Bin Laden raid.”

US District Court Judge Rudolph Contreras, however, dismissed the petition in an August 28 ruling which found that names of four CIA officials and a member of the Navy Seal team involved in planning the raid were not included in the movie, and therefore could remain secret.

“In short, Judicial Watch does not know – and outside of this suit, apparently has no way of learning – the names of these individuals,” Contreras said in his ruling.

“That fact is strong evidence that those names are not in the public domain.” The US Justice Department had argued that making the names public would create an “unnecessary security and counterintelligence risk.”

Contreras issued his decision as defendants accused in the September 11, 2001 attacks await a military ruling in a similar request, expected in a hearing later this month at the Guantanamo Bay military base.

James Connell, an attorney for one of the defendants – Ali Abd al-Aziz Ali, also known as Ammar al-Baluchi – is seeking to learn as much as the Hollywood directors got in preparation of the movie.

“The ruling that the CIA is able to hide information from the public about Zero Dark Thirty does not mean that the prosecution can hide the same information from Mr al-Baluchi's lawyers,” said Connell, whose Pakistani client is identified in the movie as the prisoner subjected to torture in a secret CIA prison.

Al-Baluchi's uncle, alleged 9/11 mastermind Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, also is to be tried at the US naval base in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.

The other defendants are Mustapha al-Hawsawi of Saudi Arabia and Yemenis Ramzi Binalshibh and Walid bin Attash.

The five face the death penalty if convicted for their roles in the 2001 attacks by al Qaeda militants in which hijacked planes were used to strike New York, Washington and Shanksville, Pennsylvania, killing 2,976 people.

The defendants have been held at the US “war on terror” detention center since 2006.

Opinion

Editorial

Harsh sentence
02 Jan, 2025

Harsh sentence

USING lawfare to swiftly get rid of political opponents makes a mockery of the legal system, especially when ...
Looking ahead
Updated 01 Jan, 2025

Looking ahead

The dawn of 2025 brings with it hope of a more constructive path to much-needed stability.
On the front lines
Updated 01 Jan, 2025

On the front lines

THE human cost of terrorism in 2024 was staggering. The ISPR reports 383 officers and soldiers embraced martyrdom...
Avoiding reform
01 Jan, 2025

Avoiding reform

PAKISTAN’S economic growth significantly slowed down to a modest 0.92pc during the first quarter of the present...
Charter of economy
Updated 31 Dec, 2024

Charter of economy

Before a consensus on economy is sought, the govt must resolve tensions with the opposition and reduce political temperatures.
Madressah compromise
31 Dec, 2024

Madressah compromise

A CLASH between the ruling coalition and the clerical old guard over the Societies Registration (Amendment) Act,...