London police fight crime with super recognisers

Published September 27, 2013
PC Paul Hyland a Metropolitan Police super recogniser poses for photographs beside computer screens at the force's New Scotland Yard headquarters in London - Photo by AP
PC Paul Hyland a Metropolitan Police super recogniser poses for photographs beside computer screens at the force's New Scotland Yard headquarters in London - Photo by AP

LONDON: Paul Hyland almost never forgets a face. He is a ''super recogniser,'' which gives an unusual kind of help to his employer: Scotland Yard.

Several years ago, London police were on the lookout for a burglar wanted for nine robberies. About a month after seeing the burglar's picture, Hyland and two colleagues were stuck in traffic.

''I looked up and noticed this guy coming out of a university and knew it was him,'' Hyland recalled, adding that neither of his colleagues recognized the burglar.

Hyland arrested the suspect, who confessed after questioning.

''If I've met someone before and see them again, I'll usually know where I know them from, even if I can't remember their name,'' he said.

How does Hyland do it? Nobody knows. But since 2011, about 200 London police officers have been recruited to an elite squad of super recognisers. Officials say they have tripled the number of criminal suspects identified from surveillance photos or on the street each week, and even helped prevent some crimes like muggings, drug deals and assaults.

''When we have an image of an unidentified criminal, I know exactly who to ask instead of sending it out to everyone and getting a bunch of false leads,'' said Mick Neville, Detective Chief Inspector at Scotland Yard.

Neville started the Super Recogniser Unit after realising the police had no system for identifying criminals based on images, unlike those for DNA and fingerprints.

The unit proved especially valuable after riots hit London in the summer of 2011. After the violence, Scotland Yard combed through hundreds of hours of surveillance video.

So far, there have been nearly 5,000 arrests; around 4,000 of those were based on police identifications of suspects from video images.

The super recognisers were responsible for nearly 30 percent of the identifications, including one officer who identified almost 300 people. In contrast, a facial recognition software program made only one successful identification, said Neville.

Weeks before the Notting Hill Carnival, the biggest street festival in Europe, kicked off last month, the super recognisers were given images of known criminals and gang members.

After the carnival began, 17 super recognisers holed up in a control room to study surveillance footage and spot the potential troublemakers.

Once targeted people were identified, police officers were sent to the scene as a pre-emptive strategy. Neville said that likely prevented some crimes like thefts and assaults.

Neville said one super recogniser saw what he thought was a drug deal, but wasn't sure.

The next day, the super recogniser saw the same person and when police intervened, they found the suspect with crack cocaine.

He noted that the officers aren't infallible and that their identification is only the start of a case, after which police start looking for other evidence.

Legal authorities warned it could be problematic to use super recognisers as expert witnesses in court, such as in situations where they identify criminals based on an imperfect image.

''Unless we subject them to (rigorous testing), then we are just taking their word on trust and we have no reason to do this,'' said Mike Redmayne, a law professor at the London School of Economics.

''Perhaps they can do what they say, but we don't have the evidence yet,'' he wrote in an email. ''If it was up to me, I would not (allow) it in court.''

In the United States (US), experts thought it would be up to individual judges to decide whether super recognisers needed to be verified before allowing their testimony in court.

''It's not clear to me that the law will demand they be tested first,'' said David Kaye, a distinguished professor of law at Penn State.

He said the identification skills of super recognisers might be analogous to those of sniffer dogs, whose ability to sniff out drugs are mostly accepted without confirmatory tests.

Kaye also noted cases where expert witnesses didn't need to have their skills verified before testifying in court and thought that in most instances, the prosecution would have more evidence than simply the identification of an alleged criminal by a super recogniser.

He said the skills of super recognisers might be more plausibly used in obtaining search warrants.

''There aren't strict rules for getting a warrant,'' Kaye said.

He added that 'the judge is supposed to exercise independent judgment but often anything goes,” and further explained that a super recogniser's identification of a suspect based on a grainy image might be sufficient to issue a search warrant.

Charles Farrier, a spokesman for the United Kingdom (UK) privacy group, No CCTV, called the police's use of super recognisers ''the latest gimmick'' being used to promote the widespread use of surveillance cameras.

According to the group, Britain has the most surveillance cameras per person in the world.

''It is a slippery slope when we want to start to justify the widespread use of blanket surveillance 'just in case' a policeman spots someone,'' he wrote in an email.

Opinion

Who bears the cost?

Who bears the cost?

This small window of low inflation should compel a rethink of how the authorities and employers understand the average household’s

Editorial

Internet restrictions
Updated 23 Dec, 2024

Internet restrictions

Notion that Pakistan enjoys unprecedented freedom of expression difficult to reconcile with the reality of restrictions.
Bangladesh reset
23 Dec, 2024

Bangladesh reset

THE vibes were positive during Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif’s recent meeting with Bangladesh interim leader Dr...
Leaving home
23 Dec, 2024

Leaving home

FROM asylum seekers to economic migrants, the continuing exodus from Pakistan shows mass disillusionment with the...
Military convictions
Updated 22 Dec, 2024

Military convictions

Pakistan’s democracy, still finding its feet, cannot afford such compromises on core democratic values.
Need for talks
22 Dec, 2024

Need for talks

FOR a long time now, the country has been in the grip of relentless political uncertainty, featuring the...
Vulnerable vaccinators
22 Dec, 2024

Vulnerable vaccinators

THE campaign to eradicate polio from Pakistan cannot succeed unless the safety of vaccinators and security personnel...