India top court refuses plea to review gay sex ban

Published January 28, 2014
Indian gay rights activists participate in a protest against the Supreme Court ruling reinstating a ban on gay sex in New Delhi. — Photo by AFP
Indian gay rights activists participate in a protest against the Supreme Court ruling reinstating a ban on gay sex in New Delhi. — Photo by AFP

NEW DELHI: India's top court Tuesday rejected a plea filed by the government and activist groups to review its shock ruling which reinstated a colonial-era ban on gay sex.

A Supreme Court bench dismissed petitions filed by the government and rights groups against a verdict last month that recriminalised gay sex and made it an offence punishable by up to life imprisonment.

“We see no reason to interfere with the order impugned. The review petitions are dismissed,” Supreme Court Justices H.L. Dattu and S.J. Mukhopadhaya said in their decision.

In its Dec 11 ruling, the top court reversed a lower court verdict from 2009 which had set aside a 1860 law outlawing “carnal intercourse against the order of nature”.

The Congress-led government filed the so-called review petition amid an outcry among activists against the December judgement.

It asked the Supreme Court to reconsider its decision to “avoid a grave miscarriage of justice to thousands of LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender) individuals”.

The government added in its petition that the ruling upholding the more than 150-year-old law was “violative of the principle of equality”.

Anand Grover, lawyer for the gay rights activist group Naz Foundation, said he was “shocked” by the Supreme Court's decision Tuesday to reject the review petitions.

But Grover told AFP that though “this battle may be lost, the war will still go on”.

The Supreme Court said in its Dec 11 ruling that responsibility for changing the law rested with lawmakers and not the courts in the sexually conservative nation.

The government and gay rights groups now have the option of filing a “curative petition”, which is the last stage of the legal appeal process and is intended to remedy gross miscarriages of justice.

But lawyers say the chances of success for such petitions are slim and the controversial issue now will likely land in parliament's lap, meaning the law could take years to change.

Observers say they see virtually no possibility parliament can reverse the law in the immediate future before national elections due by May.

The conservative Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party looks set to form the next government, according to polls.

Opinion

Editorial

Short-changed?
Updated 24 Nov, 2024

Short-changed?

As nations continue to argue, the international community must recognise that climate finance is not merely about numbers.
Overblown ‘threat’
24 Nov, 2024

Overblown ‘threat’

ON the eve of the PTI’s ‘do or die’ protest in the federal capital, there seemed to be little evidence of the...
Exclusive politics
24 Nov, 2024

Exclusive politics

THERE has been a gradual erasure of the voices of most marginalised groups from Pakistan’s mainstream political...
Counterterrorism plan
Updated 23 Nov, 2024

Counterterrorism plan

Lacunae in our counterterrorism efforts need to be plugged quickly.
Bullish stock market
23 Nov, 2024

Bullish stock market

NORMALLY, stock markets rise gradually. In recent months, however, Pakistan’s stock market has soared to one ...
Political misstep
Updated 23 Nov, 2024

Political misstep

To drag a critical ally like Saudi Arabia into unfounded conspiracies is detrimental to Pakistan’s foreign policy.