Can Brazil win the World Cup without helping Neymar?

Published July 2, 2014
Brazil's Neymar forms a heart with his hands as he leaves the pitch after the match between Brazil and Chile. — Photo by AP
Brazil's Neymar forms a heart with his hands as he leaves the pitch after the match between Brazil and Chile. — Photo by AP

FORTALEZA: As Brazil erupted when Chile's Gonzalo Jara struck the post to hand La Selecao an agonising passage to the World Cup quarter-finals on penalties, their star player Neymar collapsed in the centre-circle in tears.

His reaction a mixture of joy, relief and exhaustion, the 22-year-old is carrying the burden of a expectant nation of 200 million people as well as anyone could have hoped.

He has scored four times in as many games and also coolly slotted home Brazil's fifth and final penalty in the shootout.

However, the image of a weeping and clearly hobbled Neymar, having receiving numerous heavy challenges throughout the game, begs the question how long Brazil can continue to depend solely on the Barcelona man in attacking areas?

“We really suffered. It was pure emotion. My tears after the game were of happiness,” Neymar said after the Chile game.

“Today I had everything. I took a knock, I had cramp. Now all I want to do is rest.“ Neymar will be fit for Friday's quarter-final against Colombia, the Brazilian Football Federation have confirmed despite injuries to his thigh and hamstring.

Who will start alongside him remains a question though as neither of their two principal centre-forwards Fred and Jo have impressed in the competition so far.

Fred does have one goal to his name, a header from point-blank range into an empty net against Group A whipping boys Cameroon, but was dragged off for Jo with Brazil in need of a goal against both Chile and Mexico.

The Fluminense striker has come in for some fierce criticism, most notably from former England captain and fellow number nine Alan Shearer.

“I just don't understand why Brazil are still picking him,” Shearer said after Fred's first two disappointing performances.

“He doesn't move, he doesn't shoot and he's dragging the team down. I don't know if Brazil should change the system or play Neymar as a false nine, but the fact is that Fred is not the answer for what they are doing now. “One obvious factor keeping Fred's place in the side, though, is that Jo's form has been just as bad.

The former Manchester City man fluffed a great chance within minutes of his entrance against Chile and the fact he wasn't among Brazil's five penalty takers spoke volumes.

The storied history of Brazilian strikers at the World Cup also doesn't bode well for Neymar and company if Fred and Jo don't come good.

Despite a stellar supporting cast including Zico and Socrates, the much-maligned Serginho failed to fire them to victory in 1982.

When Brazil have succeeded, their star man has always had a wing-man. Pele had Vava, Garrincha and Jairzinho in his three triumphs, Bebeto partnered Romario in 1994 and Ronaldo led a three-pronged attack with Rivaldo and Ronaldinho in 2002.

Given Neymar's fantastic record of 35 goals in 53 appearances for his country has come in the main from starting in his preferred role on the left side means he is unlikely to move more central as Shearer suggested.

The only other option available to Luiz Felipe Scolari would be to use Hulk as a battering ram centre forward and bring an extra creative player like Willian or Bernard into the side.

Scolari's loyalty to his trusted soldiers makes it more likely he will give Fred and Jo one last go for the quarter-final against Colombia at least.

Whether that loyalty is finally rewarded or proves folly will be decided in the heat of Fortaleza on Friday.

Opinion

Editorial

Genocide resumes
Updated 19 Mar, 2025

Genocide resumes

It appears that Palestinian people will again be left defenceless in the face of merciless brutality.
Strength in unity
19 Mar, 2025

Strength in unity

WILL it count as an opportunity lost? Given the sharp escalation in militant violence in recent weeks, some had ...
NFC weightage
19 Mar, 2025

NFC weightage

THE NFC Award has long been in need of an overhaul. The government’s proposal to bring down the weightage of...
A new direction
Updated 18 Mar, 2025

A new direction

While kinetic response may temporarily disable violent actors, it will not address underlying factors providing ideological fuel to insurgencies.
BTK settlement
18 Mar, 2025

BTK settlement

WHEREVER the money goes, controversy follows. The PMLN-led federal government, which recently announced that it will...
Sugar crisis
18 Mar, 2025

Sugar crisis

GREED knows no bounds. But the avarice of those involved in the sugar business — from manufacturers to retailers...