Argentina blames US, 'incompetent' judge for default

Published July 31, 2014
Argentina defaulted on its debt for the second time in 12 years, a situation that will raise companies' borrowing costs, pile more pressure on the peso, drain dwindling foreign reserves and fuel one of the world's highest inflation rates, according to analysts. -Reuters Photo
Argentina defaulted on its debt for the second time in 12 years, a situation that will raise companies' borrowing costs, pile more pressure on the peso, drain dwindling foreign reserves and fuel one of the world's highest inflation rates, according to analysts. -Reuters Photo

BUENOS AIRES:Argentina blamed the United States Thursday for the legal battle that forced it into its second default in 13 years, accusing the judge and mediator in the case of “incompetence. “

The country officially went into default Wednesday night after the failure of 11th-hour talks with two US hedge funds refusing to accept a write-down on their Argentine bonds.

Argentine stocks plummeted 6.42 percent at the open Thursday, as the repercussions of the default began to set in.

Argentine President Cristina Kirchner's cabinet chief, Jorge Capitanich, blamed the American government for the default, brought on by a US court ruling that blocked Buenos Aires from servicing its restructured debt without also paying the hedge funds the $1.3 billion it owes them.

“If there's a judge who's an agent of these speculative funds, if the mediator is their agent, what is this justice you're talking about? There's a responsibility of the state here, of the United States, to create the conditions for the unconditional respect of other countries' sovereignty,” he told a press conference in Buenos Aires.

He accused US District Judge Thomas Griesa and court-appointed mediator Dan Pollack of “incompetence” and said Argentina would take the matter to international courts “to exercise its rights before the international community. “

Kirchner was due to give a nationally televised address Thursday evening.

Griesa, meanwhile, set a hearing on the case for Friday at 11 am (1500 GMT), a court spokesman told AFP.

Ratings agency Standard & Poor's had already placed Argentina in “selective default” before the unsuccessful end of Wednesday's marathon negotiations between Argentine Economy Minister Axel Kicillof and hedge funds NML Capital and Aurelius Capital Management.

The talks' failure caused Argentina to miss a payment of $539 million on the debt it restructured after its 2001 economic crisis.

Griesa barred the country from paying “exchange creditors” who accepted a 70-per cent write-down on their bonds without also paying the so-called “holdouts” the full $1.3 billion it owes them.

Argentina says paying the holdouts could expose it to claims for up to $100 billion from exchange creditors, who are entitled to equal treatment under what is called a Rights Upon Future Offers, or RUFO, clause.

Hedge fund NML said Argentina bore full responsibility for its own default.

“During this process, the (mediator) proposed numerous creative solutions, many of which were acceptable to us. Argentina refused to seriously consider any of them, and instead chose to default,” a spokesman said.

But Argentina complained that the creditors, which bought defaulted Argentine bonds at knockdown rates, then sued for full payment, had refused to compromise.

“What we offered them in terms of profit was 300 per cent. It was not accepted, because they want more, and they want it now,” Kicillof said.

The economy minister slammed S&P's downgrade, arguing Argentina could not be regarded as being in default since the money for the repayment was in a US bank account but frozen by Griesa's court order.

“Argentina paid. It has money. It is going to continue to pay. The one who is responsible for this situation is Judge Griesa,” he said.

The Bank of New York said Thursday that it continued to hold onto Argentina's $539-million debt payment, saying it was sitting in the US bank's account at Argentina's central bank because of Griesa's ruling.


Aftershocks of 2001


Wall Street and the Buenos Aires stock exchange opened sharply lower Thursday following news of Argentina's default.

Argentine stocks tumbled 6.42 per cent, while the Dow Jones Industrial Average, S&P 500 and Nasdaq were also down.

Argentine press reports, however, suggested an alternative solution was being prepared in which a coalition of Argentine private banks would buy some or all of the outstanding debt.

Argentina got a show of support from French Finance Minister Michel Sapin, who said he was “extremely shocked” by the outcome of the legal battle.

“This undermines a decision taken in everyone's interest” to restructure Argentina's debt, he said, warning the court ruling would jeopardize future debt restructuring for countries in crisis.

Analysts have warned the default will deepen the economic malaise gripping Argentina, exacerbating its already unruly inflation, prices rose 15 per cent in the first half of the year, and perhaps forcing another devaluation of the peso, already devalued 20 per cent in January.

Argentina's 2001 default on $100 billion in foreign debt, the largest in history at the time, plunged the country into an economic and social crisis it is still battling to overcome.

But the global impact of the new default will be far smaller, since Argentina has been locked out of international capital markets since its 2001 default, analysts say.

Follow Dawn Business on Twitter, LinkedIn, Instagram and Facebook for insights on business, finance and tech from Pakistan and across the world.

Opinion

Editorial

Risky slope
Updated 17 Dec, 2024

Risky slope

Inflation likely to see an upward trajectory once high base effect tapers off.
Digital ID bill
Updated 17 Dec, 2024

Digital ID bill

Without privacy safeguards, a centralised digital ID system could be misused for surveillance.
Dangerous revisionism
Updated 17 Dec, 2024

Dangerous revisionism

When hatemongers call for digging up every mosque to see what lies beneath, there is a darker agenda driving matters.
Remembering APS
Updated 16 Dec, 2024

Remembering APS

Ten years later, the state must fully commit itself to implementing NAP if Pakistan is to be rid of terrorism and fanaticism.
Cricket momentum
16 Dec, 2024

Cricket momentum

A WASHOUT at The Wanderers saw Pakistan avoid a series whitewash but they will go into the One-day International...
Grievous trade
16 Dec, 2024

Grievous trade

THE UN’s Global Report on Trafficking in Persons 2024 is a sobering account of how the commodification of humans...