Mosque tragedy

Published September 12, 2014
Residents and rescue workers gather at the site of a mosque, after its roof collapsed, in Lahore September 9, 2014. At least 25 people were trapped and two killed when the mosque roof caved in on Tuesday, local television reported. REUTERS/Mohsin Raza (PAKISTAN - Tags: DISASTER RELIGION)
Residents and rescue workers gather at the site of a mosque, after its roof collapsed, in Lahore September 9, 2014. At least 25 people were trapped and two killed when the mosque roof caved in on Tuesday, local television reported. REUTERS/Mohsin Raza (PAKISTAN - Tags: DISASTER RELIGION)

AS workers continue to sift through the rubble of Jamia Masjid Hanifia in Lahore’s Daroghawala area, several families are mourning the over 20 people who died on Tuesday when the mosque’s second storey collapsed.

Those fortunate enough to survive say that there was a loud bang immediately followed by the caving in of the newly constructed roof. Within minutes, say eyewitnesses, the whole edifice had turned to rubble.

What makes the episode even more tragic is the all-too-common reason: substandard construction and additions to the original design on the one hand, and the lack of governmental oversight in ensuring that building requirements were met on the other.

Also Read: Eighteen killed in Lahore after mosque roof collapses

Five or six years ago, the mosque administration decided to expand the 40-year-old building whose design had not been approved by the district administration since the government then was still some decades away from issuing no-objection certificates.

Unfortunately, it also bypassed consultation with any architect or civil engineer whose concern it is to ensure that a building is structurally sound and safe for the purpose for which it will be used.

The result was a second storey resting on inadequate foundations.

This made the collapse more or less inevitable.

While the mosque administration must of course be taken to task for its negligence, the city administrative apparatus must equally shoulder the blame for not enforcing the standards that are thoroughly spelt out by the law.

Also Read: Bad civil work made mosque death trap

The fact is that across the country, it is routine for structures — whether mosques, houses, buildings or any other construction — to be built in violation of the structural requirements, and without government agencies ensuring that all rules and regulations are complied with.

In terms of mosques, their administrations, too, often play a controversial role: any questions about mosque expansion are usually met with outrage, and the issue is distorted through a religious lens.

Tuesday’s tragedy should serve as a wake-up call: building codes need to be urgently enforced, and not only the administration but the citizens themselves need to recognise their importance.

Published in Dawn, September 12th, 2014

Opinion

Editorial

Poll petitions’ delay
Updated 06 Jan, 2025

Poll petitions’ delay

THOUGH electoral transparency and justice are essential for the health of any democracy, the relevant quarters in...
Migration racket
06 Jan, 2025

Migration racket

A KEY part of dismantling human smuggling and illegal migration rackets in the country — along with busting the...
Power planning
06 Jan, 2025

Power planning

THE National Electric Power Regulatory Authority, the power sector regulator, has rightly blamed poor planning for...
Confused state
Updated 05 Jan, 2025

Confused state

WHEN it comes to combatting violent terrorism, the state’s efforts seem to be suffering from a lack of focus. The...
Born into hunger
05 Jan, 2025

Born into hunger

OVER 18.2 million children — 35 every minute — were born into hunger in 2024, with Pakistan accounting for 1.4m...
Tourism triumph
05 Jan, 2025

Tourism triumph

THE inclusion of Gilgit-Baltistan in CNN’s list of top 25 destinations to visit in 2025 is a proud moment for...