Govt asks Supreme Court to overturn ban on hunting houbara bustards

Published November 12, 2015
Attorney General Amir Rehman argued that controlled hunting “is a tool for preservation so it should be allowed”. —Reuters/File
Attorney General Amir Rehman argued that controlled hunting “is a tool for preservation so it should be allowed”. —Reuters/File

ISLAMABAD: The government on Thursday asked the Supreme Court to review its ban against hunting a rare desert bird whose meat is prized among Arab sheikhs as an aphrodisiac, saying controlled hunting could be a tool for preservation.

A three-judge bench comprising Chief Justice Anwar Zaheer Jamali, Justice Sheikh Azmat Saeed and Justice Qazi Faez Isa heard the review petitions moved separately by the federal and provincial governments seeking reconsideration of the court’s decree which banned foreign dignitaries from hunting the vulnerable migratory bird houbara bustard.

Wealthy hunting parties from the Gulf travel to Baluchistan province every winter to kill the houbara bustard using hunting falcons, a practice that has sparked controversy in recent years because of the bird's dwindling numbers.

The issue has also cast a spotlight on traditionally close ties between Pakistan and its allies in the Arab world, particularly Saudi Arabia.

The restrictions on hunting the bird were having a negative impact on Pakistan’s already weakened relations with the Gulf states in the wake of turmoil in the region, the review petition said.

The federal government had also reminded the court that the judiciary usually avoided interfering in the executive’s affairs.

It said falconry was not merely a sport for Arabs, but one of their most cherished customs, which was also recognised as an intangible cultural heritage by Unesco.

In August the Supreme Court banned hunting of the houbara bustard in a decision welcomed by wildlife campaigners.

But the federal and provincial governments asked the court to review the decision, with the deputy attorney general Amir Rehman arguing on Thursday that controlled hunting “is a tool for preservation so it should be allowed”.

“Conservation efforts cannot be successful without economic benefits for the communities,” Rehman told a three-member bench headed by Chief Justice Anwar Zaheer Jamali.

He also said the court had not considered scientific evidence presented by the government, nor had it taken into account provincial laws allowing for the hunting of the houbara bustard.

However panel member Qazi Faez Isa said the government move would “hasten “the demise of the bird, adding: “You want to reduce Pakistan to a desert.”

“Can't they do it in their own country?” he asked, referring to the Arab sheikhs and their annual hunting trip to Pakistan.

The court adjourned the hearing for three weeks and asked Rehman to bring more data about the population of the bird and preservation efforts.

The International Union for Conservation of Nature includes the bird on its “red list” of threatened species, estimating there are fewer than 97,000 left globally.

Baluchistan High Court in November last year cancelled all permits for hunting in the province, but the federal government headed by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif — a close ally of Saudi Arabia — continued to issue licenses.

Opinion

Editorial

Desperate measures
Updated 27 Dec, 2024

Desperate measures

Sadly in Pakistan, street protests and sit-ins have become the only resort to catch the attention of a callous power elite.
Economic outlook
27 Dec, 2024

Economic outlook

THE post-pandemic years, marked by extreme volatility in the global oil and commodity markets as well as slowing...
Cricket and visas
27 Dec, 2024

Cricket and visas

PAKISTAN has asserted that delay in the announcement of the schedule of next year’s Champions Trophy will not...
Afghan strikes
Updated 26 Dec, 2024

Afghan strikes

The military option has been employed by the govt apparently to signal its unhappiness over the state of affairs with Afghanistan.
Revamping tax policy
26 Dec, 2024

Revamping tax policy

THE tax bureaucracy appears to have convinced the government that it can boost revenues simply by taking harsher...
Betraying women voters
26 Dec, 2024

Betraying women voters

THE ECP’s recent pledge to eliminate the gender gap among voters falls flat in the face of troubling revelations...