KARACHI: Readers of the satire website Khabaristan Times were informed in a Facebook post on Monday that the website had been blocked in Pakistan since Wednesday (Jan 25).

According to the post: “...there hasn’t been an official notification from any regulatory authority regarding the website being banned, but it can’t be accessed anywhere in Pakistan. We’ll keep you posted, if there are any updates.”

However, the website can be accessed from outside the country and through different virtual private networks (VPNs) in Pakistan.

A source at the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority said the website had been blocked after receiving complaints about “objectionable content”.

Khabaristan Times (KT), which started in 2014, has a steady following with more than 12,000 likes on Facebook and around 1,000 followers on Twitter. It is run by journalists with tongue-in-cheek commentary on Pakistani politics and the military. Satirical commentaries with controversial headlines like ‘PML-N, PPP relations nosedive as Nawaz receives Zardari’s intimate selfies with Trump’ have often appeared on this website.


PTA yet to issue an official notification in this regard


Talking to Dawn, KT’s CEO Luavut Zahid said Kunwar Khuldune Shahid, the editor, was in Australia at the time when he told her to check if the website might have been blocked in Pakistan. “We learned that it was working at his end but not mine,” she said.

Ms Zahid claimed that they were yet to receive an official notification regarding the block.

“We have blogged for Pakistan Today...when we began KT, the thing on our minds was that we didn’t want to deal with management and those who ask editors to take pieces down.”

According to the website’s editor, he found out that the website had been blocked after a reader sent him a message about it.

He explained that they had decided not to react immediately. “We posted a message on Monday after confirming it. We had to check if there was something wrong tech-wise at our end or if it had indeed been blocked.”

“We haven’t contacted the PTA directly... considering how the situation has been in the last month but we have spoken to them indirectly and they claimed it was because they had received complaints about the material after which they monitored the website and then blocked it,” he explained.

According to Mr Shahid, the website could have been blocked because of two aspects of the publication’s satire — “criticism of the establishment and candid and sometimes blatant critique of religious extremism.”

Farieha Aziz of Bol Bhi, a digital rights organisation, explained that prior to the enactment of the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act 2015-16, “to block a website, [complainants] would have to go through an inter-ministerial committee which would then direct the PTA, which would tell internet service providers (ISPs) and they would then block website...after the [passage of the] Prevention of Electronic Crimes Bill, however, the PTA has the full authority to block ‘unlawful content’.”

She said, “As far as KT is concerned, the PTA could do this. If you pick up the law, the PTA has become the direct complaint centre — this is exactly what we were afraid of...they have become the judge, jury and executioner...they [KT] will have to take it up with the PTA or a high court to get their website unblocked.”

Published in Dawn January 31st, 2017

Opinion

Editorial

Mineral wealth
Updated 10 Apr, 2025

Mineral wealth

The Baloch unrest is partly the result of the belief that the province’s resources are being used for the rest of the country rather than for Balochistan’s economic development.
Senate shortfalls
10 Apr, 2025

Senate shortfalls

THE latest Citizens’ Report by Pildat on the performance of the Senate of Pakistan is a sobering account of...
Crypto coup
10 Apr, 2025

Crypto coup

IT is quite the coup. One of the most recognisable names in the global cryptocurrency market has been roped in by ...
Following through
Updated 09 Apr, 2025

Following through

Reconciliation, development, and deradicalisation initiatives cannot remain dormant words in a policy document.
Robe rebellion
09 Apr, 2025

Robe rebellion

THE unrest within the Islamabad High Court shows no sign of abating, and it is perhaps just as well that the ...
Fearing birth
09 Apr, 2025

Fearing birth

AMID dramatic aid cuts, the WHO has sounded the alarm about the dangers to Pakistan’s mothers and newborns, asking...