From Nawaz, to Shahbaz, to Hamza: the game of Pakistani dynastic politics continues

Published July 31, 2017
Former prime minister Nawaz Sharif (right) and Punjab Chief Minister Shahbaz Sharif (left) embrace after the Supreme Court announced its verdict in the Panama Papers case on April 20. 
 — File
Former prime minister Nawaz Sharif (right) and Punjab Chief Minister Shahbaz Sharif (left) embrace after the Supreme Court announced its verdict in the Panama Papers case on April 20. — File

Ousted prime minister Nawaz Sharif has passed the leadership baton to his brother, ensuring the continuation of a dynastic political system in a country where government has long been run as a family enterprise.

In Pakistan's stratified, semi-feudal society, patronage and kinship play a huge role in politics, often dominating ideology.

Some analyst estimates say that more than half of seats — at both national and provincial level — have been passed from father to son, brother to brother, keeping the business of politics firmly within the family.

Sharif named his younger brother Shahbaz as his successor to the country's top office in a defiant speech the day after he was disqualified by the Supreme Court.

The move maintains PML-N's hold on power, with Nawaz continuing to act as puppet master from his position as head of the party.

“The subtext in all this is that Nawaz Sharif will still have an influence in how things are carried out until the next election and perhaps through the next election,” said political analyst Umair Javad.

“This was his (Nawaz's) way of convincing the party that this brand still exists.”

Shahbaz is expected to slide into his brother's vacated National Assembly seat before being rubber stamped as prime minister in a parliamentary vote.

Meanwhile, Shahbaz is reportedly lining up his son Hamza to take his position as Punjab chief minister, though he too must first be elected to his father's provincial assembly seat in a by-election.

“It's the confidence of a political dynasty in its power that's allowing it to make all these moves,” said Badar Alam, editor of the Herald magazine.

“They feel that in certain parts of the country their dynastic hold is so strong that no challenge can uproot them.”

But some warn that the PML-N will not rally behind Shahbaz — considered less charismatic than his older brother — in the same way that it did Nawaz, possibly fracturing the party.

“Nawaz has personal political appeal in a way that his brother doesn't. I think that the dynasty will fray under his brother,” said journalist and commentator Omar Waraich.

'Stronger brand'

Another power dynasty, the Bhutto family and its PPP lost its footing after Benazir Bhutto's death.

Since Benazir's assassination, the PPP has become a shadow of its former self, and lost 76 seats in the last 2013 general election.

“The leaders have a much stronger brand than the parties. Benazir was always a much stronger brand than the Pakistan People's Party. Nawaz Sharif is a much stronger brand than what the PML-N will be without him,” said Waraich.

Similarly, the Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf is ultimately centred around the personality of its chief Imran Khan.

“One of the appeals of Imran Khan is that he breaks this dynastic hold. But he only does it through the form of a personality cult,” said Waraich.

Khan held a rally attended by thousands of dancing, celebrating supporters late Sunday in which he criticised the dynastic nature of the Sharif transfer of power.

“Is there no one else in your (Sharif's) party to make prime minister?” he asked the festive crowd. “It's not democracy, it's a kingdom.”

The outgoing Sharif now has to face down corruption allegations that have swept up three of his children, including his daughter Maryam Nawaz who had long been touted as his presumptive political heir.

The family will likely be in and out of court for the next six months as investigators pick over every detail of their luxury lifestyle and extensive wealth.

“It is a serious blow to dynastic politics that has been the biggest impediment to the development of democratic institutions and values in the country,” said author and journalist Zahid Hussain in his recent op-ed for Dawn, referring to the Supreme Court judgement that ousted Sharif.

But, he concluded, while the death knell of Sharif's political career has arguably been sounded, “one is not sure if the family rule is over”.

Opinion

Editorial

Geopolitical games
Updated 18 Dec, 2024

Geopolitical games

While Assad may be gone — and not many are mourning the end of his brutal rule — Syria’s future does not look promising.
Polio’s toll
18 Dec, 2024

Polio’s toll

MONDAY’s attacks on polio workers in Karak and Bannu that martyred Constable Irfanullah and wounded two ...
Development expenditure
18 Dec, 2024

Development expenditure

PAKISTAN’S infrastructure development woes are wide and deep. The country must annually spend at least 10pc of its...
Risky slope
Updated 17 Dec, 2024

Risky slope

Inflation likely to see an upward trajectory once high base effect tapers off.
Digital ID bill
Updated 17 Dec, 2024

Digital ID bill

Without privacy safeguards, a centralised digital ID system could be misused for surveillance.
Dangerous revisionism
Updated 17 Dec, 2024

Dangerous revisionism

When hatemongers call for digging up every mosque to see what lies beneath, there is a darker agenda driving matters.