The Supreme Court (SC) on Tuesday overturned the death sentence awarded to a murder convict by a Pakpattan trial court in 2006, converting the sentence into life imprisonment.

The trial court had handed Ghulam Mustafa a death sentence over a decade ago for murdering his paternal uncle and the uncle's five children.

The decision had previously been upheld by the trial court and high court before it was referred to the SC.

A three-judge bench, headed by Justice Asif Saeed Khosa, overturned the high court's decision today, saying that there were no witnesses to the murder, and that neither robbery nor rivalry appeared to be the motives behind the crime.

The court said that as the motive remains a mystery, it would err on the side of caution.

Justice Dost Muhammad observed that although provinces spend millions on prosecution, it remains inefficient.

"In countries like Israel, even the prime minister comes under fire if the prosecution writes even half a page against him," Justice Dost Muhammad said referring to a 2012 case where former Israeli prime minister Ehud Olmert was handed a $19,000 fine and a suspended jail sentence for being guilty of breach of trust in a corruption case.

Justice Dost Muhammad lamented that those who are assigned responsibilities do not perform their duties.

He illustrated the point by alluding to former military dictator Ziaul Haq. "Some here created fasaad years ago, while others had to undertake operations against fasaad to get rid of the menace many years on," he said in an apparent reference to counter-terror Operation Raddul Fasaad.

"We must stop playing with human lives," he added.

Opinion

Editorial

Agriculture tax
Updated 16 Nov, 2024

Agriculture tax

Amendments made in Punjab's agri income tax law are crucial to make the system equitable.
Genocidal violence
16 Nov, 2024

Genocidal violence

A RECENTLY released UN report confirms what many around the world already know: that Israel has been using genocidal...
Breathless Punjab
16 Nov, 2024

Breathless Punjab

PUNJAB’s smog crisis has effectively spiralled out of control, with air quality readings shattering all past...
Last call
Updated 15 Nov, 2024

Last call

PTI should hardly be turning its "final" protest into a "do or die" occasion.
Mini budget talk
15 Nov, 2024

Mini budget talk

NO matter how much Pakistan’s finance managers try to downplay the prospect of a ‘mini budget’ to pull off a...
Diabetes challenge
15 Nov, 2024

Diabetes challenge

AMONGST the many public health challenges confronting Pakistan, diabetes arguably does not get the attention it...