Treason case: LHC orders removal of Cyril Almeida's name from ECL, withdraws warrants

Published October 8, 2018
(L-R) Dawn Assistant Editor Cyril Almeida, ousted prime minister Nawaz Sharif, and former prime minister Shahid Khaqan Abbasi.
(L-R) Dawn Assistant Editor Cyril Almeida, ousted prime minister Nawaz Sharif, and former prime minister Shahid Khaqan Abbasi.

Former prime ministers Nawaz Sharif and Shahid Khaqan Abbasi and Dawn Assistant Editor Cyril Almeida appeared before a full bench of the Lahore High Court (LHC) on Monday for hearing of a petition seeking treason proceedings against the two ex-PMs and journalist.

As the hearing commenced, the three-judge bench comprising justices Syed Mazahar Ali Akbar Naqvi, Atir Mahmood and Chaudhry Masood Jahangir ─ which had in the last hearing placed Almeida's name on the Exit Control List and issued non-bailable warrants for his arrest for not attending previous court proceedings ─ ordered that the journalist's name be removed from the no-fly list and the warrants withdrawn.

Dawn Assistant Editor Cyril Almeida and Editor Dawn Zaffar Abbas arrive at the LHC. ─ Photo courtesy Ayesha Tanzeem, Voice of America
Dawn Assistant Editor Cyril Almeida and Editor Dawn Zaffar Abbas arrive at the LHC. ─ Photo courtesy Ayesha Tanzeem, Voice of America

Almeida's counsel Ahmed Rauf told the court that at the last hearing, he had stated that he was informed over the phone about the petition and was not even aware of the content. Prior to Monday's hearing, the lawyer had already filed written replies and comments on behalf of Almeida.

Editor Dawn Zaffar Abbas had already announced that Almeida is a law-abiding citizen and would definitely appear before the court on Oct 8. He said that the notice served on Almeida was delivered at Dawn’s Islamabad bureau in the middle of last week, and journalists and officials at the bureau said the earlier two notices were never delivered. Abbas was also in court today.

Sharif, who was recently released from jail after receiving bail in the Avenfield case, had also been absent from previous hearings as he had been receiving condolences over the death of his wife.

Former PM Nawaz Sharif arrives at the LHC. ─ DawnNewsTV
Former PM Nawaz Sharif arrives at the LHC. ─ DawnNewsTV

Sharif, Abbasi and Almeida's attendance was noted and all three respondents were ordered to submit written replies to the court and appear before the bench on Oct 22.

Absence of AG

"What action has the government taken with respect to Article 6?" Justice Jahangir asked.

"This case is related to the Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority (Pemra)," Deputy Attorney General Mian Tariq responded.

"Pemra's job is to prevent broadcasts of speech. Taking action under Article 6 is the government's job," Justice Jahangir noted. He added: "This is a sensitive issue."

Irked at the absence of the attorney general, Justice Naqvi ordered that he attend the next hearing on Oct 22 and submit a complete report on the matter.

A local lawyer Afaq Ahmed today filed a petition requesting that the treason case be set aside, arguing that it was not in accordance with law, and did not hold the signature of the petitioner but instead of her lawyer. High court rolls do not allow action on such petitions, Ahmed maintained.

Ahmed asked the court to make him party to the treason petition and scrap the case against Sharif. The maintainability of the petition must be assessed. It was not taken up by the court today.

Security was tight around LHC premises, with a contingent of Rangers and police officials deployed outside the court, and greater vigilance at the entry and exit points of the court.

The controversy

Former PM Shahid Khaqan Abbasi arrives at the LHC. ─ DawnNewsTV
Former PM Shahid Khaqan Abbasi arrives at the LHC. ─ DawnNewsTV

Civil society member Amina Malik, had filed the petition on the basis of an interview given by Sharif to Dawn on May 11. According to the petition, the former PM spoke about cross-border militancy and the need to end it.

After the publication of the interview, the National Security Council held a meeting to deliberate on the matter. Shahid Khaqan Abbasi, who was prime minister at the time, called on Sharif to take him into confidence about the deliberations.

According to the petitioner, Abbasi’s action amounted to sedition as he had violated his oath of office.

Opinion

Editorial

Ukraine initiative
21 Feb, 2025

Ukraine initiative

THOUGH Donald Trump has not been able to fulfil his promise of ending the Ukraine conflict “24 hours” after...
High cost of SOEs
21 Feb, 2025

High cost of SOEs

THERE are losses and then some. The finance ministry’s latest overview of the federally owned state enterprises...
Poor impression
21 Feb, 2025

Poor impression

RECENT developments in the Senate have provided cause for concern on how parliamentary business is being conducted....
Premature alarm
Updated 20 Feb, 2025

Premature alarm

Improvement in headline inflation gives policymakers chance to fix investment policies, implement structural reforms.
Forsaken province
20 Feb, 2025

Forsaken province

AND the endless cycle of violence continues. The brutal killing on Tuesday night of seven Punjab-bound passengers in...
In poor health
20 Feb, 2025

In poor health

THE absence of decent and affordable healthcare in the country continues to ruin lives. An example of this is ...