Environmental concerns abound as Pakistan goes against the grain with coal power spree

Published November 15, 2018
Chinese Technical Director Yan Bing Bing (R) talking with a co-worker at an open-pit coal mining site at Islamkot in Tharparkar. ─AFP
Chinese Technical Director Yan Bing Bing (R) talking with a co-worker at an open-pit coal mining site at Islamkot in Tharparkar. ─AFP

In the bleak Thar desert, the roar of trucks is constant at a massive Chinese-backed coal power project the government sees as an answer to chronic energy shortages, but which activists warn is an environmental disaster.

Machines are running round the clock to finish the mine and coal power plant, a flagship project of the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) plan that has seen Beijing provide billions of dollars in financing to Islamabad.

Trucks transporting soil in an open-pit coal mining site at Islamkot. ─AFP
Trucks transporting soil in an open-pit coal mining site at Islamkot. ─AFP

Much of it is for infrastructure and power in order to prevent blackouts which have infuriated citizens and hamstrung the economy for years.

Read more: Earth could become unliveable if greenhouse emissions continue rising at current rates: report

And while coal is going out of vogue in most other parts of the world because of its environmental impact, it will fuel nine of the 17 proposed CPEC power plants.

The one in Thar sits atop 175 billion tonnes of coal ─ one of the largest deposits in the world.

Discovered in 1992, it has remained unexploited until now, but is expected to yield 3.8 million tonnes a year when fully operational.

A Chinese-backed power plant under construction in Islamkot. ─AFP
A Chinese-backed power plant under construction in Islamkot. ─AFP

A few kilometres away, towering chimneys emerge from the sand dunes as Pakistani and Chinese workers toil away on a 660-megawatt power plant which will burn coal from the mine.

After struggling for years to upgrade its power infrastructure, various Pakistani leaders have touted CPEC as a "game changer" that will help lift the ailing economy, dismissing concerns that Chinese financing will lead to unsustainable debts and that the projects are boosting Beijing's interests at Islamabad's expense.

Sindh Engro Coal Mining Company CEO Shamsuddin Shaikh gestures during an interview at his office in Karachi. ─AFP
Sindh Engro Coal Mining Company CEO Shamsuddin Shaikh gestures during an interview at his office in Karachi. ─AFP

Know more: Economy vs environment: Thar coal and a test of Pakistan's priorities

"We are five months ahead of schedule," said Sindh Engro Coal Mining Company (SECMC) Director General Shams Shaikh. The SECMC, a joint China-Pakistan venture, has invested around $1.9bn in the Thar mine-and-plant project.

Experts say the site should be able to produce 200,000 MW of electricity over the next hundred years ─ a boon for the energy-starved country where demand increases by 8 per cent each year, according to official statistics.

Water warning

Despite the fanfare and government assurances, the project has triggered concern about its impact on the environment.

The type of coal in Thar is lignite, notorious for its poor energy efficiency and high carbon dioxide emissions.

Project officials insist its operations will comply with national and international environmental laws.

Read more: ‘Climate change is a bigger threat to Pakistan than terrorism’

But mining coal and burning it for power are water-intensive activities, and villagers in this impoverished, vast stretch of desert say the project is playing havoc with local supplies.

A worker starting a water drawing pump at a site to store water which will be used at a Chinese-backed power plant under construction in Islamkot. ─ AFP
A worker starting a water drawing pump at a site to store water which will be used at a Chinese-backed power plant under construction in Islamkot. ─ AFP

Underground rivers which previously flowed into the mine have been diverted, and residents of Gorano, a small village some 25 kilometres (15 miles) from the coal project, claim their pastures have been transformed into a salt lake due to water diversions and the dumping of waste.

“It's complete chaos,” said Raja who goes by one name, while another local, Yameen Bhatti, added: “The (diverted) water has attracted mosquitoes, which spread diseases.”

Chinese workers walking in a Chinese-backed power plant under construction in Islamkot. ─ AFP
Chinese workers walking in a Chinese-backed power plant under construction in Islamkot. ─ AFP

SECMC says it has given 950 million rupees ($7 million) to the community as compensation, but after the floodwaters recede, experts warn the residents will probably continue to struggle as the thirsty power project will consume a huge amount of ground water.

Environmental concerns about Pakistan's coal spree go beyond the villages of Thar. The UN has warned that the country risks an “absolute” water shortage by 2025, and activists have warned about the impact of such industries on increasingly scarce water supplies.

Officials have said that the country's new coal plants will use the most efficient technology available to minimise pollution.

Coal vs renewable energy

Pakistan's push to build coal-fired plants comes amid a global drive to replace fossil fuels with renewable energy like solar and wind.

“While the rest of the world is abandoning coal, we are throwing ourselves into this disaster,” said Omar Cheema, an environmental expert.

Read more: Special Report: Why climate change is a real threat for Pakistan

Some experts and officials have also suggested it would be cheaper to invest in renewables as the price of solar and wind is dropping, and several international studies have also shown that coal is no longer competitive.

Irfan Yousuf, director of renewables at the Ministry of Energy, estimated the per-kilowatt price of solar power at 4.8 rupees, compared with 8.5 rupees for coal.

But Pakistani authorities argue that using local coal would help cut fuel imports, saving precious billions in foreign exchange, and would also provide reliable power round the clock, unlike fluctuating output from renewable sources.

Read more: Pakistan can produce renewable energy. So why do we continue to import pricey fossil fuels?

Some have compared Pakistan with neighbouring India, which has announced ambitious plans to invest in renewable energy. But India is heavily dependent on coal, which provides more than 75 percent of its electricity.

In Pakistan, it accounts for less than one percent.

Follow Dawn Business on Twitter, LinkedIn, Instagram and Facebook for insights on business, finance and tech from Pakistan and across the world.

Opinion

Editorial

Counterterrorism plan
Updated 23 Nov, 2024

Counterterrorism plan

Lacunae in our counterterrorism efforts need to be plugged quickly.
Bullish stock market
23 Nov, 2024

Bullish stock market

NORMALLY, stock markets rise gradually. In recent months, however, Pakistan’s stock market has soared to one ...
Political misstep
Updated 23 Nov, 2024

Political misstep

To drag a critical ally like Saudi Arabia into unfounded conspiracies is detrimental to Pakistan’s foreign policy.
Kurram atrocity
Updated 22 Nov, 2024

Kurram atrocity

It would be a monumental mistake for the state to continue ignoring the violence in Kurram.
Persistent grip
22 Nov, 2024

Persistent grip

An audit of polio funds at federal and provincial levels is sorely needed, with obstacles hindering eradication efforts targeted.
Green transport
22 Nov, 2024

Green transport

THE government has taken a commendable step by announcing a New Energy Vehicle policy aiming to ensure that by 2030,...