ISLAMABAD: A senior member of the Pakistan Bar Council (PBC) on Monday expressed his scepticism through a letter to the body, suggesting that it reconsider its demand to fill the vacant office of a judge in the Supreme Court through elevation among lawyers.

Recently, the executive committee of the PBC demanded appointment from lawyers to serve on the bench in the Supreme Court against the current vacancy after superannuation of retired Justice Sheikh Azmat Saeed.

In the letter to the PBC, Raheel Kamran Sheikh proposed a number of suggestions by stating that he was somewhat sceptical about the demand put forth by the executive committee.

As the Latin maxim said that the law was written on sleeves of the judges, competence was a necessary but not sufficient condition to be a good judge, the letter says, adding that juristic ability, temperament, sense of responsibility and above all sense of justice and fairness were a few other pre-requisites for becoming a judge.

A brilliant lawyer might turn out to be a disappointment as a judge, the letter says, adding that this might well be because of the differences in the roles and absence of one or more of these prerequisites. Should the Supreme Court, which is the ultimate forum for the dispensation of justice, be made a testing ground to ascertain one’s abilities to serve on the bench, the letter poses a question.

It goes on to say that at the high courts level, the practice of appointments as Additional Judges for a certain period serves the system better, otherwise all those who were not confirmed would have been serving on the bench notwithstanding one or the other shortcoming.

“Indeed it does carry with it the fear that an additional judge may hesitate to act boldly in certain types of cases, however, the benefits clearly outweigh such limited conservatism as the process carries with it a good possibility of re-evaluating credentials to serve on the bench after initial appointment,” the letter said.

Published in Dawn, September 3rd, 2019

Opinion

Editorial

China security ties
Updated 14 Nov, 2024

China security ties

If China's security concerns aren't addressed satisfactorily, it may affect bilateral ties. CT cooperation should be pursued instead of having foreign forces here.
Steep price
14 Nov, 2024

Steep price

THE Hindu Kush-Himalayan region is in big trouble. A new study unveiled at the ongoing COP29 reveals that if high...
A high-cost plan
14 Nov, 2024

A high-cost plan

THE government has approved an expensive plan for FBR in the hope of tackling its deep-seated inefficiencies. The...
United stance
Updated 13 Nov, 2024

United stance

It would've been better if the OIC-Arab League summit had announced practical measures to punish Israel.
Unscheduled visit
13 Nov, 2024

Unscheduled visit

Unusual IMF visit shows the lender will closely watch implementation of programme goals to prevent it from derailing.
Bara’s businesswomen
13 Nov, 2024

Bara’s businesswomen

Bara’s brave women have proven that with the right support, societal barriers can be overcome.