LHC dismisses Meesha Shafi's appeal in harassment case against Ali Zafar

Published October 11, 2019
The Lahore High Court on Friday disposed off a petition filed by singer Meesha Shafi in a harassment case lodged by her against fellow artist Ali Zafar. — Dawn.com/File
The Lahore High Court on Friday disposed off a petition filed by singer Meesha Shafi in a harassment case lodged by her against fellow artist Ali Zafar. — Dawn.com/File

The Lahore High Court on Friday disposed of a petition filed by singer Meesha Shafi in a harassment case lodged by her against fellow artist Ali Zafar.

In the appeal, filed in August 2018, Shafi had challenged the Punjab ombudsperson (Protection against Harassment of Women at Workplace) and governor's decision to dismiss her complaint against Zafar whom she accused of sexual harassment.

On October 2, Justice Shahid Kareem reserved the verdict in the case after hearing final arguments by lawyers.

Shafi had initially filed a complaint accusing Zafar of harassment with the provincial ombudsperson, who had rejected it on technical grounds saying that as she and Zafar "did not have an employer-employee relationship", the case could not be heard in that forum.

She then appealed against the decision before the Punjab governor, whom her legal team considered the competent authority to review any decisions made by the ombudsperson.

However, the Punjab governor upheld the ombudsperson's decision in July 2018, dismissing her request on "technical grounds".

Shafi had subsequently approached the LHC to challenge the governor's decision.

Representing Shafi, Barrister Ahmed Pansota and Saqib Jilani had told the court that the Punjab governor had dismissed their client's appeal by upholding the opinion that the ombudsperson's office was not the appropriate forum to hear such a complaint.

The counsel argued that it was not a prerequisite for two parties to have an employer-employee relationship in a case of sexual harassment, and that the provincial ombudsperson could be approached with a complaint regarding sexual harassment at the workplace.

The petition requested the court to declare invalid the governor's decision to dismiss Shafi's complaint and to order the initiation of proceedings against Zafar for harassment.

On the other hand, the counsel for Zafar had argued that the case did not fall under the law concerning harassment at the workplace.

Opinion

Editorial

Some progress
Updated 27 Mar, 2025

Some progress

The hard-won macroeconomic stability is only a short distance away from a deeper crisis.
Time to talk
27 Mar, 2025

Time to talk

IN an encouraging development, the government has signalled openness to PPP chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari’s ...
Black Sea truce
27 Mar, 2025

Black Sea truce

WHILE the Trump administration may have no problem with Israel renewing its rampage in Gaza, it is playing ...
Kabul visit
Updated 26 Mar, 2025

Kabul visit

Islamabad should continue to emphasise that presence of terrorists on Afghan soil stands in the way of normal commercial ties.
Drought warning
26 Mar, 2025

Drought warning

DRIVEN by rising temperatures linked to climate change, increasing drought events across Pakistan have affected tens...
Deadly roads
26 Mar, 2025

Deadly roads

DESPITE daytime restrictions on heavy vehicles, Karachi continues to witness one horrific traffic accident after...