PBC asks govt to refrain from filing reference against Justice Seth

Published February 4, 2020
PBC chairman says statement was issued in a preventive move to offset any government decision to file the reference.
PBC chairman says statement was issued in a preventive move to offset any government decision to file the reference.

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan Bar Council (PBC) vice chairman Abid Saqi on Monday asked the federal government to refrain from filing any reference before the Supreme Judicial Council (SJC) against Justice Waqar Ahmed Seth, Chief Justice of the Peshawar High Court, who presided over the special court that handed down the death penalty to former president Pervez Musharraf in a high treason case.

The PBC vice chairman cautioned the government in a statement that the council would not hesitate to launch a countrywide agitation against the government if any move was made to file the reference before the SJC under Article 209 of the government against Justice Seth.

When contacted, Abid Saqi told Dawn that the statement was issued in a preventive move to offset any government decision to file the reference.

Moreover, a senior government functionary confided to Dawn that no serious consideration was under way to file any reference against Justice Seth, especially in view of the fact that references were filed on misconduct and not on any judgement of the superior court judge.

The statement said the Dec 17, 2019 verdict of the special court which was also authored by Justice Waqar Ahmed Seth was a brave and historic judgement since for the first time in the judicial history of Pakistan a decision had come against a military dictator for having subverted the constitution.

That judgement was not only welcomed but also appreciated and commended by the entire nation as a whole particularly by the legal fraternity since it not only strengthened the principle of supremacy of the constitution, the rule of law and the independence of the judiciary but also ensured continuity of the democratic process as enshrined in the constitution.

The perceived decision of the federal government to file the reference against Justice Seth, the statement said, was a cause of grave concern and any such move will be based on ulterior motives aiming to target and suppress the independence of the judiciary.

The legal fraternity had also reacted sharply to the filing of the references against Justice Qazi Faez Isa of the Supreme Court as well as Justice K.K. Agha of the Sindh High Court on misconduct.

A 10-judge full court of the Supreme Court is also seized with a set of challenges to the filing of the presidential references against Justice Isa.

Published in Dawn, February 4th, 2020

Opinion

Editorial

Genocide resumes
Updated 19 Mar, 2025

Genocide resumes

It appears that Palestinian people will again be left defenceless in the face of merciless brutality.
Strength in unity
19 Mar, 2025

Strength in unity

WILL it count as an opportunity lost? Given the sharp escalation in militant violence in recent weeks, some had ...
NFC weightage
19 Mar, 2025

NFC weightage

THE NFC Award has long been in need of an overhaul. The government’s proposal to bring down the weightage of...
A new direction
Updated 18 Mar, 2025

A new direction

While kinetic response may temporarily disable violent actors, it will not address underlying factors providing ideological fuel to insurgencies.
BTK settlement
18 Mar, 2025

BTK settlement

WHEREVER the money goes, controversy follows. The PMLN-led federal government, which recently announced that it will...
Sugar crisis
18 Mar, 2025

Sugar crisis

GREED knows no bounds. But the avarice of those involved in the sugar business — from manufacturers to retailers...