Fertiliser sector subsidy ineffective to control commodity prices: study

Published August 10, 2021
A farmer works in the field in Fata. — Photo courtesy: Tariqullah
A farmer works in the field in Fata. — Photo courtesy: Tariqullah

KARACHI: Direct and indirect subsidies to the fertiliser industry are an ineffective policy tool in the quest to ensure low prices of essential commodities like wheat, rice, maize and sugar for low-income people, a research paper released on Monday said.

The research paper released by the Pakistan Institute of Development Economics said the government spends roughly Rs200 billion every year on subsidising the fertiliser industry — funds that have “negligible” contribution to the reduction of prices, it said.

About 84 per cent of Pakistan’s total fertiliser demand is met through local production while the gap is plugged through imports. Local prices of urea remained lower than international prices in the last 10 years mainly because of an indirect subsidy on feedstock gas, which is the primary raw material used in making fertiliser.

Call for diversion of funds towards development of production technologies, rural infrastructure

Around 80pc of the gas supplied to the fertiliser industry is for feedstock. A differential of Rs721 per million cubic British thermal units exists between feedstock and fuel stock prices. This price differential accounts for Rs150bn per annum, but does not include the tax relief to the fertiliser industry.

“In addition to these subsidies, the government also provides a subsidy of Rs1,194 per 50kg bag on imported urea. “The aggregate subsidy of the federal government to the fertiliser sector is more than Rs200bn per annum and the subsidies given by the provinces are in addition to this,” the paper said.

Pricing and profits

The retail price of a 50kg urea bag was Rs1,686 in 2020-21 after a subsidy of Rs865 per bag on feedstock gas. About 65pc of the retail price (Rs1,096 per bag) constituted the cost of production while the remaining 35pc (Rs590) was the profit that was divided among different stakeholders, including production units, the research paper said.

However, the selling price of urea would have increased to Rs2,551 per bag if the subsidy on feedstock gas amounting to Rs865 per bag was withdrawn. “This cost structure of the urea bag demonstrates that fertiliser companies are earning a certain profit from the fertiliser subsidy rather than maintaining a ‘reasonable’ threshold level of urea prices for farmers,” it said.

To establish the scope of the subsidies received by the fertiliser industry, the research paper compared this amount with the federal Public Sector Development Programme (PSDP) budget of Rs650bn for 2020-21. “If we add up other subsidies in terms of tax relief and provincial subsidies and incentives to the fertiliser industry, then it accounts for... 31pc and 22pc of federal PSDP for 2020-21 and 2021-22, respectively,” it said.

In 2020-21, the fertiliser industry generated a cumulative net profit of Rs80.4bn, which was more than half of the subsidy in terms of the feed-fuel price differential.

Published in Dawn, August 10th, 2021

Follow Dawn Business on Twitter, LinkedIn, Instagram and Facebook for insights on business, finance and tech from Pakistan and across the world.

Opinion

Editorial

Smog hazard
Updated 05 Nov, 2024

Smog hazard

The catastrophe unfolding in Lahore is a product of authorities’ repeated failure to recognise environmental impact of rapid urbanisation.
Monetary policy
05 Nov, 2024

Monetary policy

IN an aggressive move, the State Bank on Monday reduced its key policy rate by a hefty 250bps to 15pc. This is the...
Cultural power
05 Nov, 2024

Cultural power

AS vital modes of communication, art and culture have the power to overcome social and international barriers....
Disregarding CCI
Updated 04 Nov, 2024

Disregarding CCI

The failure to regularly convene CCI meetings means that the process of democratic decision-making is falling apart.
Defeating TB
04 Nov, 2024

Defeating TB

CONSIDERING the fact that Pakistan has the fifth highest burden of tuberculosis in the world as per the World Health...
Ceasefire charade
Updated 04 Nov, 2024

Ceasefire charade

The US talks of peace, while simultaneously arming and funding their Israeli allies, are doomed to fail, and are little more than a charade.