Sugar mills’ pleas against new price referred to appellate panel

Published October 1, 2021
A file photo of the Lahore High Court. — AFP/File
A file photo of the Lahore High Court. — AFP/File

LAHORE: The Lahore High Court has referred the petitions of the sugar mills against forced lifting of the commodity and its new price to an appellate committee available in the law as a first remedy with a direction to decide the controversy strictly in accordance with law.

During Wednesday’s hearing, a deputy attorney general had told the court that the petitioners could raise the issue before the appellate forum provided under section 6 of the Price Control and Prevention of Profiteering and Hoarding Order 2021.

The millers’ counsel said due to absence of any express power in the rules of the appellate forum to grant interim relief, they approached the court under the constitutional jurisdiction.

However, they said the petitions could be referred to the appellate authority as applications for interim relief and the respondents be restrained from implementing the impugned orders till a decision.

To substantiate the plea of irreparable loss, the counsel argued that there was no mechanism of recovering the amount from the consumers, to whom sugar was being supplied, even if the appellate forum decided the matter in favour of the millers.

In his written order issued on Thursday, Justice Shahid Jamil Khan says, “Observing judicial restraint to give any observation of finding on the issue, the matter is referred to appellate authority, ibid, which shall treat these petitions as applications for interim relief.”

In the interest of justice, the judge directed that till decision on the applications the impugned orders of the government shall not be implemented.

With these directions, the judge disposed of the petitions of the sugar mills.

The counsel for the millers told the court that legality of the Punjab Sugar (Supply Chain Management) Order 2021 was also challenged in the petitions.

The judge allowed the petitioners to raise the matter later through a fresh litigation.

Published in Dawn, October 1st, 2021

Opinion

Editorial

Ultimate price
Updated 02 Nov, 2024

Ultimate price

To dismantle culture of impunity for crimes against journalists, state must ensure that perpetrators do not go unpunished.
Mastung bombing
02 Nov, 2024

Mastung bombing

INSTABILITY continues to haunt Balochistan, as Friday morning’s bombing in Mastung has shown. At least nine...
Plane speak
02 Nov, 2024

Plane speak

DESPITE all its efforts to facilitate PIA’s privatisation, it seems the government only ended up being taken for a...
Seeking investment
Updated 01 Nov, 2024

Seeking investment

Foreign visits will be fruitless unless crucial structural, policy reforms directly affecting investors are focused.
State-backed terror
01 Nov, 2024

State-backed terror

OVER the past year or so, India’s reportedly malign activities in foreign countries have increasingly come under the radar, with
Shared crisis
01 Nov, 2024

Shared crisis

WITH Lahore experiencing unprecedented levels of smog, the Punjab government has announced a series of “green...