Justice Isa asks CJP Bandial to withdraw names rejected by JCP in July

Published October 24, 2022
This file photo shows Justice Qazi Faez Isa. — Photo courtesy SC website
This file photo shows Justice Qazi Faez Isa. — Photo courtesy SC website

ISLAMABAD: Justice Qazi Faez Isa, the senior puisine judge of the Supreme Court, has requested Chief Justice of Pakistan (CJP) Umar Ata Bandial to withdraw the names of the three junior judges who have been rejected by the Judicial Commission of Pakistan (JCP) in its last meeting of July 28.

“I most humbly request the Hon’ble Chairman to act constitutionally, legally and morally and withdraw the names of those junior judges who have already been rejected by the JCP,” Justice Isa requested in his Oct 21 letter to Justice Bandial who is JCP’s chairman.

The letter, partially reported on Saturday, was written against the backdrop of Monday’s scheduled meeting of the commission to consider nomination of Justice Shahid Waheed of Lahore High Court, Justice Syed Hasan Azhar Rizvi and Justice Shafi Siddiqui of Sindh High Court, besides Islamabad High Court Chief Justice Athar Minallah, for their elevation to the apex court.

On Oct 22, Pakistan’s legal fraternity raised concerns over the move to reconsider for elevation to the Supreme Court the names of three judges, months after JCP had ‘rejected’ them, with the lawyers’ community vowing to challenge any such nomination, even if approved by the JCP in its Monday meeting.

The Pakistan Bar Council (PBC), the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) and the Sindh Bar Council (SBC) have expressed concern through resolutions.

Says reconsideration disparages and disrespects JCP members

In his letter, Justice Isa asked the CJP to consider putting forward the names of the chief justices of the five high courts or, as proposed by two JCP members earlier, the chief justices together with the senior most judges of the five high courts, failing which let this constitute the agenda of the forthcoming meeting.

‘Secret recording’

Referring to the recording of the last meeting of JCP on July 28 and then the release of its audio recording, Justice Isa regretted that the chairman did not disclose to the members then that the meeting was being “secretly recorded” and even did not take permission from JCP before releasing the audio.

If it had been disclosed that the meeting was being recorded and that its recording may be released, the members may have been more circumspect in expressing their views. Regrettably, the releasing of the audio by the head of the judiciary had undermined the credibility and authority of serving judges of the high court, the letter said.

The letter alleged that the chairman had also contradicted himself in the note when he stated that the JCP meeting was being “resumed” on Oct 24. The resumption of the meeting, after a period of about three months, was alien to the law and common sense, it said.

In any event, the composition of JCP has undergone a change since the last meeting, since one member has been retired and Justice Syed Mansoor Ali Shah has become its member.

How the July meeting could be stated to be resumed on Oct 24 with a different agenda, he wondered.

Published in Dawn, October 24th, 2022

Opinion

Revival? For whom?

Revival? For whom?

Numerous sets of numbers, not quoted by govt sources, suggest that things are not as dazzling as claimed by those who run the country.

Editorial

Premature alarm
Updated 20 Feb, 2025

Premature alarm

Improvement in headline inflation gives policymakers chance to fix investment policies, implement structural reforms.
Forsaken province
20 Feb, 2025

Forsaken province

AND the endless cycle of violence continues. The brutal killing on Tuesday night of seven Punjab-bound passengers in...
In poor health
20 Feb, 2025

In poor health

THE absence of decent and affordable healthcare in the country continues to ruin lives. An example of this is ...
Out of control
Updated 19 Feb, 2025

Out of control

AS bodies continue to fall in Kurram despite a state-sanctioned ceasefire, one wonders how long local militants’...
Hollow words
19 Feb, 2025

Hollow words

IT is not uncommon for politicians to resort to the use of hyperbole in order to boost their public standing. ...
Migration matters
19 Feb, 2025

Migration matters

THE grass, it seems, did appear greener on the other side to millions of people as evidenced by the latest UN ...