LAHORE: The Lahore High Court has ruled that the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) enjoys exemption from property tax on its im­movable properties situa­ted in cantonment areas.

Justice Jawad Hassan issued the ruling allowing a petition of the SBP challe­nging the levy of property tax by the Chaklala Canton­ment Board, Rawalpindi and seeking an exemption under Section 99(2)(f) of the Cantonments Act, 1924.

The SBP through a counsel pleaded that it was a corporation but not a commercial entity like the National Bank of Pakistan or any other commercial/scheduled bank or financial institution.

The counsel argued that by granting property tax exemption to the SBP, no discrimination will be caused to any entity. He said over the years there have been many amendments in the functions of the SBP which justify its claim for grant of exemption from payment of property tax under the Cantonments Act.

He contended that the SBP, by virtue of its powers and functions, was wholly owned by the federal government and performed functions on behalf of the government and was also mentioned in the Fourth Schedule, Part I, Federal Legislative List at Item No. 28 of the Constitution and these functions have been given to the central bank through an amendment made in the act as well as other applicable laws.

Besides questioning the maintainability of the central bank’s petition, a counsel for the board argued that the SBP was a corporation, hence, it was not entitled to property tax exemption. He also said that the bank estopped by its own conduct to claim exemption because payment of tax had already been made by its other office.

In his 23-page judgement, Justice Hassan observed that the functions of the SBP are functions of the federal government because the regulatory powers conferred on it, through the SBP Act as well as other laws, cover a broad range of areas which play a vital role in the country’s economy.

Looking into the ownership of share capital of the SBP, the judge noted that since promulgation of the bank’s act in 1974, 49 per cent shares were vested in the general public, therefore, no exemption was earlier claimed and practice of payment of property tax was continued.

Thereafter, he said, in 2015 certain amendments were made in the law and the entire share capital was vested in the federal government and was also non-transferable.

The judge observed that tax on immovable properties is a provincial subject and Article 165 of the Constitution is relevant in context of determining the application of property tax on the SBP.

Most importantly, he noted, the contesting respondents nowhere denied or brought on record any law, rules or regulations that the federal government cannot own property through a corporation.

“The exercise of sovereign powers by the petitioner (SBP) and performance of public service in the premises owned by it makes out a perfect case for grant of exemption from payment of property tax,” Justice Hassan maintained.

The judge held that the question that the SBP had been paying property tax previously is immaterial and does not even arise because if a right originates by provision of a law then such right cannot be withheld simply on the basis of estoppel.

The judge ruled that the title of the property in occupation of the SBP indeed vests in the federal government and the cantonment board has no authority to levy and demand property tax from the bank.

Allowing the petition, the judge set aside the notices/challan forms laying a demand for payment of property tax from the SBP for being without lawful authority and of no legal effect.

Published in Dawn, November 10th, 2022

Opinion

Editorial

Smog hazard
Updated 05 Nov, 2024

Smog hazard

The catastrophe unfolding in Lahore is a product of authorities’ repeated failure to recognise environmental impact of rapid urbanisation.
Monetary policy
05 Nov, 2024

Monetary policy

IN an aggressive move, the State Bank on Monday reduced its key policy rate by a hefty 250bps to 15pc. This is the...
Cultural power
05 Nov, 2024

Cultural power

AS vital modes of communication, art and culture have the power to overcome social and international barriers....
Disregarding CCI
Updated 04 Nov, 2024

Disregarding CCI

The failure to regularly convene CCI meetings means that the process of democratic decision-making is falling apart.
Defeating TB
04 Nov, 2024

Defeating TB

CONSIDERING the fact that Pakistan has the fifth highest burden of tuberculosis in the world as per the World Health...
Ceasefire charade
Updated 04 Nov, 2024

Ceasefire charade

The US talks of peace, while simultaneously arming and funding their Israeli allies, are doomed to fail, and are little more than a charade.