Struck down

Published August 12, 2023

JUST a day after the 15th National Assembly was dissolved, the Supreme Court reversed one of its key legislative interventions in the judicial domain by striking down the Supreme Court (Review of Judgements and Orders) Act of 2023.

A three-member bench of the apex court unanimously held the law “repugnant and ultra vires to the Constitution”, ruling that converting the apex court’s review jurisdiction into an appellate jurisdiction required a constitutional amendment.

It may be recalled that the law in question would have allowed affected parties to appeal any judgement or order, passed by the Supreme Court in exercise of its original jurisdiction under Article 184(3), before a larger bench.

The facility had been extended retrospectively, with critics saying this had been done to give Nawaz Sharif and Jahangir Tareen an opportunity to have their sentences overturned.

It may be recalled that the PDM government had passed several laws affecting the superior judiciary amidst a stand-off triggered by a petition challenging unconstitutional delays in elections to the KP and Punjab assemblies.

The enactment of the Review of Judgements and Orders Act, in particular, had taken the apex court by surprise, forcing it to indefinitely adjourn proceedings on a review petition filed by the ECP against an earlier ruling on election timelines.

Referencing the circumstances in which the law was passed, the Supreme Court ruled that ordinary legislation that interferes with the independence of the judiciary is “unconstitutional, null, void and of no legal effect” from its inception.

As regards the impact of this judgement on Nawaz Sharif’s disqualification status, the outgoing law minister has said it does not matter as the amended Elections Act now limits the length of disqualification of lawmakers to five years with retrospective effect.

However, it would appear that the ECP may face new difficulties as it defends its decision to disregard constitutional timelines for elections that have become due.

Exactly a week earlier, the apex court issued a detailed judgement elaborating on its April 4 short order on the ECP’s decision to postpone polls, in which it excoriated the election watchdog for taking an unconstitutional step despite a Supreme Court order directing that elections in Punjab be held latest by May 14.

With no means of appealing that judgement now at its disposal, it will be interesting to see how the ECP responds.

Published in Dawn, August 12th, 2023

Opinion

Editorial

Smog hazard
Updated 05 Nov, 2024

Smog hazard

The catastrophe unfolding in Lahore is a product of authorities’ repeated failure to recognise environmental impact of rapid urbanisation.
Monetary policy
05 Nov, 2024

Monetary policy

IN an aggressive move, the State Bank on Monday reduced its key policy rate by a hefty 250bps to 15pc. This is the...
Cultural power
05 Nov, 2024

Cultural power

AS vital modes of communication, art and culture have the power to overcome social and international barriers....
Disregarding CCI
Updated 04 Nov, 2024

Disregarding CCI

The failure to regularly convene CCI meetings means that the process of democratic decision-making is falling apart.
Defeating TB
04 Nov, 2024

Defeating TB

CONSIDERING the fact that Pakistan has the fifth highest burden of tuberculosis in the world as per the World Health...
Ceasefire charade
Updated 04 Nov, 2024

Ceasefire charade

The US talks of peace, while simultaneously arming and funding their Israeli allies, are doomed to fail, and are little more than a charade.