Organisers accused of negligence over Brazil-Argentina brawl

Published November 24, 2023
RIO DE JANEIRO: Argentinian football fans clash with police at the Maracana Stadium.—AFP
RIO DE JANEIRO: Argentinian football fans clash with police at the Maracana Stadium.—AFP

RIO DE JANEIRO: Brazilian police and football authorities tra­ded blame Wednesday after a br­a­wl broke out ahead of Brazil’s ma­tch against arch-rivals Argen­tina, leaving several injured in what fans called a “tragedy foretold.”

Brazil’s football fan clubs association, ANATORG, said government authorities and the Brazilian Football Confederation (CBF) were “negligent” in seating rival fans next to each other at Tuesday’s epic clash in Rio de Janeiro’s Maracana stadium, with no barriers separating them.

The 2026 World Cup qualifier, which Argentina won 1-0, had to be delayed for around 30 minutes when rival fans started throwing punches before kickoff.

Police fought back the melee wi­th batons, leaving some fans with bloodied faces and other injuries.

“The negligence and incompetence of the CBF and security officials resulted in the brawl,” said ANATORG, which had issued a statement on Monday warning of the risk of violence, given the mixed seating plan. “This was a tragedy foretold.”

FIFA president Gianni Infan­tino meanwhile said there is “abso­lut­ely no place for violence in football.”

“Players, fans, staff and officials have to be safe and secure,” he wrote on Instagram.

The iconic stadium descended into chaos Tuesday night, as players tried in vain to get fans to stop the fray. Argentina captain Lionel Messi led his team back to the dre­ssing room, returning only after the violence had been quelled.

Rio state police called the events “deplorable,” and accused the CBF of meeting with its commanders to discuss security plans only after tickets had sold out with a mixed seating plan.

“The CBF decided to release tickets for sale without country quotas and, worse, without delimiting separate seating areas,” it said in a statement.

The CBF rejected accusations of negligence. “State police and other authorities were aware of the plan to use mixed seating, which is the standard for matches organised by FIFA,” it said in a statement.

“The organisation and planning of the match were carefully and strategically carried out by the CBF, together with the authorities, especially the police.”

After the match, Messi criticized the police “repression” of fans, posting on social media: “This can’t be tolerated! It’s craziness, it needs to stop.”

Published in Dawn, November 24th, 2023

Opinion

Editorial

Economic plan?
Updated 15 Dec, 2024

Economic plan?

So long as the government does not realise that it needs to put its own house in order, growth will remain anaemic and the world will be reluctant to help.
Registration tussle
15 Dec, 2024

Registration tussle

MAULANA Fazlur Rehman appears to be having trouble digesting the fact that he was taken for a ride. The government,...
Dangerous overreach
15 Dec, 2024

Dangerous overreach

THE latest wave of arrests and cases filed against journalists and social media users under Peca marks an alarming...
Half measures
Updated 14 Dec, 2024

Half measures

The question remains: Were suspects' prolonged detention, subsequent trial, and punishments ever legal in eyes of the law?
Engaging with Kabul
14 Dec, 2024

Engaging with Kabul

WHILE relations with the Afghan Taliban have been testy of late, mainly because of the feeling in Islamabad that the...
Truant ministers
Updated 14 Dec, 2024

Truant ministers

LAWMAKERS from both the opposition and treasury benches have been up in arms about what they see as cabinet...