ISLAMABAD: The proposed restructuring of the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has heightened uncertainty within the field formation due to escalating tensions among tax groups concerning the nature and extent of the reforms, Dawn has learned from knowledgeable sources.

This uncertainty could potentially affect revenue collection, a concern that is particularly significant given the current political instability that has already strained the country’s economy. The FBR is struggling to recover its revenue collection, yet it remains on track to meet the target committed with the International Monetary Fund (IMF).

On Nov 16, 2023, Caretaker Finance Minister Shamshad Akhtar announced in Karachi that the customs will be separated from the Inland Revenue Services (IRS). This decision came as a big surprise for both tax officials and taxpayers, as they were not previously aware of this significant change.

Last week, the Special Investment Facilitation Council declared that it had authorised the proposal but had formed a ministerial committee to determine its legal obligations. The restructuring plan will receive final clearance in a cabinet meeting, according to a senior tax official, who added that everything is still a suggestion and nothing has been finalised.

Tensions between Customs, Inland Revenue threaten collection

Since the announcement, the divide between the tax groups—Customs and IRS—has deepened over the nature of the reforms. The IRS group believes that the changes have been proposed by a select few customs officers and are being backed by Ms Akhtar.

The proposed reforms are marked by three broad indicators— the establishment of three distinct boards to oversight the functions and policy formulation of the FBR. This reform will create a policy board to develop income tax, sales tax and federal excise duty policies. Private sector members will serve on this finance minister-headed body.

Two oversight and governance bodies will be established for the IRS and Customs. These boards will be chaired by the Finance Minister’s nomination, who may be an ex-tax official or specialist. These boards will also have members from the private sector. There will be no chairman of FBR, but rather a chairman of the boards. Currently, there is a National Tariff Policy Board which is chaired by the commerce minister.

Sources close to the development informed Dawn that the proposed reforms in the FBR structure were kept confidential. Most of the senior tax officials at FBR were not privy to the key features of these proposed reforms.

Dawn made multiple attempts to reach out to FBR Chairman Zubair Tiwana for his feedback but he didn’t pick up calls nor respond to messages sent on his cellphone. The FBR spokesperson also did not answer.

Director generals will replace present FBR members under reforms. Thus, IRS and Customs will have DGs. The tax collection structure and method will not change in the field formation.

An IRS senior official told Dawn that the finance minister had been briefed on the probable consequences of the planned oversight boards. The appointments of private sector members may lead to conflict of interest.

The minister was also warned of serious accountability difficulties. The official wondered who would keep private sector board members accountable.

The FBR Act empowers its members, and the current revisions propose giving board members comparable rights, which could cause governance concerns. No calculation shows that reforms will increase revenues, the minister was informed.

“The minister is not heeding our recommendations,” the official source said, adding that she will make a final decision with the cabinet before Feb 8 as caretaker minister.

The planned revisions also divide customs officials. Some officers feel a separate board will allow them to act independently of the IRS group chairman and board officers. Others support the current system with an emphasis on field formation and revenue collection integrity.

Published in Dawn, January 12th, 2024

Follow Dawn Business on Twitter, LinkedIn, Instagram and Facebook for insights on business, finance and tech from Pakistan and across the world.

Opinion

Editorial

Islamabad protest
Updated 20 Nov, 2024

Islamabad protest

As Nov 24 draws nearer, both the PTI and the Islamabad administration must remain wary and keep within the limits of reason and the law.
PIA uncertainty
20 Nov, 2024

PIA uncertainty

THE failed attempt to privatise the national flag carrier late last month has led to a fierce debate around the...
T20 disappointment
20 Nov, 2024

T20 disappointment

AFTER experiencing the historic high of the One-day International series triumph against Australia, Pakistan came...
Tribunals’ failure
Updated 19 Nov, 2024

Tribunals’ failure

With election tribunals having failed to fulfil their purpose, it isn't surprising that Pakistan has not been able to stabilise.
Balochistan MPC
19 Nov, 2024

Balochistan MPC

WHILE immediate threats to law and order must be confronted by security forces, the long-term solution to...
Firm tax measures
19 Nov, 2024

Firm tax measures

FINANCE Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb is ready to employ force to make everyone and every sector in Pakistan pay their...