Rehabilitation of displaced families is Sindh govt’s responsibility: SC

Published April 4, 2024
A view of some demolished houses along Gujjar Nullah.—White Star/file
A view of some demolished houses along Gujjar Nullah.—White Star/file

KARACHI: The Supreme Court on Wednesday directed the Sindh government to fulfil its responsibility for rehabilitating over 6,900 families rendered homeless by a demolition drive, which was carried out along with three major drains in the city.

The apex court also asked them to obtain the estimated cost of construction from the Pakistan Engineering Council (PEC) for building of houses for such displaced families.

Outside the premises of the SC Karachi registry, a large number of the affected people, including women, gathered and staged a protest against the government for failing to rehabilitate them despite the passage of around three years.

When a two-judge bench headed by Justice Mohammad Ali Mazhar took up the matter for hearing, the Sindh chief secretary and advocate general were not in attendance.

Victims of demolition drive stage protest as 6,900 families still await compensation; construction cost for 80sq-yds plot is Rs3.7m, court told

The court expressed resentment over their absence and directed them to immediately appear in court. Thereafter, both the officials appeared and informed the bench about implementation on its earlier orders regarding compensation and rehabilitation of displaced families.

A lawyer for the displaced families argued that instead of seeking cost of construction from the PEC in line the court order, the provincial government was getting the cost estimates from its own consultants while as per PEC the cost for construction of a house measuring 80 square yards stood around Rs3.7 million.

However, the chief secretary submitted that the houses were built for flood-affected families and the construction cost of a two-room house was Rs300,000.

He submitted that the issue about the cost of construction would be placed before the provincial cabinet.

The bench said that the rehabilitation of these families was the responsibility of the Sindh government and directed it to fulfil the same.

It asked the provincial authorities to get the estimated cost of construction from the PEC and file a report on April 8.

The bench also directed the chief secretary to appear in court on the next hearing.

The provincial authorities in the statement placed before the bench said that in the light of the apex court order passed in December, the provincial cabinet in January had approved the rehabilitation of displaced families including provision of 80 sq-yd plot for each family in Taiser Town, Malir and construction cost as estimated by the consultant capped at Rs1 million.

It further stated that there were 6,932 such families and the total cash compensation for construction was Rs6.9 billion which would be paid to the affected people by the Sindh government.

The statement also maintained that a committee comprising professors of the NED University, renowned architects, representatives of affected families and others would oversee the whole process.

The authorities had sought six-month time from the court for completing the process of transfer of plots and disbursement of cash compensation for construction.

The demolition drive was carried out on the orders of the Supreme Court along with three major nullahs of the city in order to expand the drains.

In 2021 the apex court ordered the provincial and local authorities for compensation and rehabilitation of the affected and displaced families.

Published in Dawn, April 4th, 2024

Opinion

The fallout

The fallout

Faced with an untrustworthy trade partner in the US, the economic imperative for countries would be to pursue trade diversion.

Editorial

April heat
Updated 14 Apr, 2025

April heat

A much broader and more cohesive plan is needed to meet Pakistan’s changing requirements amidst an accelerating climate crisis.
ADB’s advice
14 Apr, 2025

ADB’s advice

WITH the Trump administration’s trade war on China and the rest of the world having led to global economic...
‘Land of the free’
14 Apr, 2025

‘Land of the free’

IN Trumpian America, even those foreigners with legal status are finding that the walls are closing in on them. As...
Caught in between
Updated 13 Apr, 2025

Caught in between

In the absence of a trade agreement, under WTO rules, Pakistan cannot reduce duty rates for the US without doing the same for other countries.
Spirit of giving
13 Apr, 2025

Spirit of giving

THE recent declaration by ulema affirming that organ donation after death is not only permissible but an act of...
Targeting dissent
13 Apr, 2025

Targeting dissent

THE recent notice sent by the FIA to former senator Farhatullah Babar is deeply troubling — and revealing....