ACCORDING to Article 248(1) of the country’s Constitution, the president, governor, prime minister, federal ministers, ministers of state, chief ministers and provincial ministers “shall not be answerable to any court for the exercise of powers and performance of functions of their respective offices or for any act done or purported to be done, in the performance of those functions”.

Likewise, according to Article 248(2), “no criminal proceedings whatsoever shall be instituted against the president or a governor during his term of office”.

Moreover, Article 248(3) stipulates that “no process for arrest or imprison-ment of the president or a governor shall issue from a court during his term of office”.

Prima facie, these and such other provisions of the Constitution, which describes the country as an ‘Islamic republic’, happen to be in sharp contrast to the tenets and teachings of Islam. Historically, none of the four caliphs ever enjoyed any such immunity, and all were answerable to the courts.

It is unfortunate that such un-Islamic and undemocratic provisions exist in the Constitution in a country where all laws are expected to be in line with Islamic teachings. The Council of Islamic Ideology (CII), whose primary responsibility is to identify such inconsistencies, continues to be negligent in this regard.

The democratic government in office as well as the two houses of parliament should join hands to undo the un-Islamic clauses guaranteeing immunity so that the ruling elite may stand answerable to a court of law like any law-abiding citizen of the country. The CII should also look at the inconsistency and make necessary recommendations in this regard.

M. Sharafat Ali Zia
Islamabad

Published in Dawn, May 5th, 2024

Opinion

Editorial

Tribunals’ failure
Updated 19 Nov, 2024

Tribunals’ failure

With election tribunals having failed to fulfil their purpose, it isn't surprising that Pakistan has not been able to stabilise.
Balochistan MPC
19 Nov, 2024

Balochistan MPC

WHILE immediate threats to law and order must be confronted by security forces, the long-term solution to...
Firm tax measures
19 Nov, 2024

Firm tax measures

FINANCE Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb is ready to employ force to make everyone and every sector in Pakistan pay their...
When medicine fails
Updated 18 Nov, 2024

When medicine fails

Between now and 2050, medical experts expect antibiotic resistance to kill 40m people worldwide.
Nawaz on India
Updated 18 Nov, 2024

Nawaz on India

Nawaz Sharif’s hopes of better ties with India can only be realised when New Delhi responds to Pakistan positively.
State of abuse
18 Nov, 2024

State of abuse

The state must accept that crimes against children have become endemic in the country.