Divided land, disputed origins: India’s Brokpa people

Published July 16, 2024
Leh: Brokpa ethnic community’s women gather at a house in Ladakh’s Garkon village.—AFP
Leh: Brokpa ethnic community’s women gather at a house in Ladakh’s Garkon village.—AFP

GARKON: High in the icy Indian Himalayas, a long-isolated people recall origin myths of millennia-old migrations from afar — an identity in disputed lands twisted today by politics.

The Brokpa people of Ladakh have no written language, practise a culture of polygamy, and have their own calendar.

The most cherished ballad of the Brokpa, some 6,000 of whom live in a rugged mountain valley of the Indus river, is the “song of history”. A new verse is added every 12 years, a cycle which counts as just one “year” in their calendar.

Tsering Gangphel, 85, said it details Brokpa legends that they came from ancient Rome. Other Brokpa people recount myths of ancestral links to Alexander the Great’s army, who invaded in the fourth century BC.

Scientists are sceptical, with one study of Brokpa DNA suggesting their roots lay in southern India. But Gangphel — who said he can sing a thousand songs in the Brokpa language detailing their culture — is adamant about his people’s past.

“We still celebrate our arrival here by dancing and singing in each village, once every three years,” Gangphel said, at his home overlooking the roaring river. “We are Aryans,” he added.

The deeply contested term refers to opaque pre-history — which critics say is today more about gritty realpolitik than foundation fables.

‘Validate their hold’

In South Asia’s ancient Sanskrit language, “aryan” means “noble” or “distinguished”, not a separate ethnicity. It was once a loose term suggesting that people from Europe to Asia had linked ancestors in Central Asia, reflected in common linguistic roots.

That is a far cry from the genocidal Nazi fantasies of a blond-haired and blue-eyed master race. Some right-wing Hindus use the term to claim “Aryan” ancestors originated in India, linking it to a Hindu and national identity.

For the Brokpa, the term “Aryan” has been used as a tool to promote both tourism and India’s geopolitical ambitions.

After the Kargil fighting stopped, Indian authorities pushed tourism in Brokpa areas calling their lands the “Aryan Valley”. The tourism ministry promotes them as the “Last Aryan Villages of India”.

Mona Bhan, a Brokpa expert at Syracuse University in New York, says the community uses “Aryan” to highlight its socio-cultural practices and history.

But Indian Hindu nationalists have used the term to “validate their hold on India’s disputed territory”, according to the anthropologist.

‘It’s a sin’

The Brokpa calendar means a child’s first birthday is marked when they turn 12. Using that calculation, a laughing and grey-haired Gangphel remarked that he is “just seven years old”.

Gangphel, a father of six who has two wives, said marrying outsiders was frowned upon. “Being Brokpa means being unique in language, dress and dance,” said 14-year-old schoolgirl Etzes Dolma.

But an influx of tourists and government development policies are bringing increasing modernity. Earth and wood homes are being replaced with concrete and glass construction.

The Brokpa worship their traditional gods, but those now are often amalgamated into other beliefs. Most Brokpas in India are Buddhists, while in Pakistan many have become Muslim.

Published in Dawn, July 16th, 2024

Opinion

Editorial

Signs of trouble
22 Aug, 2024

Signs of trouble

The administration cannot leave people in the affected areas at the mercy of terrorists.
Plugging the gap
22 Aug, 2024

Plugging the gap

IF fiscal prudence is a virtue then Pakistan’s budgets have been an exercise in vice for the last many years. This...
Karachi accident
22 Aug, 2024

Karachi accident

TWO innocents are dead. Amina, 26, and her father, Imran Arif, 60, were killed this Monday when a speeding SUV ...
Troubled tribunals
Updated 21 Aug, 2024

Troubled tribunals

Systems meant to act as a check and balance on our institutions and ensure compliance with the constitutional order keep failing us constantly.
Ceasefire farce
21 Aug, 2024

Ceasefire farce

AS Israel continues to mercilessly pound Gaza, the US pushes the fiction that a ceasefire is close in the besieged...
Silencing expression
21 Aug, 2024

Silencing expression

THE return of Aun Ali Khosa, a satirist and social media activist, has brought much relief to his family and...