Beggars galore

Published December 13, 2024

SOCIAL media posts as well as some reports in the conventional media suggest a family of beggars from Gujranwala spent Rs2.5 million on a mourning ritual. This is far more than what most middle-class families earn annually. For comparison, a salaried individual earning this much in a year would pay a significant amount in income tax, whereas the beggars contribute nothing. Such a situation is not only a national embarrassment, but also a clear sign of the failure of the system to control professional beggary.

The business of professional beggary raises serious ethical and legal concerns. Laws to control beggery do exist, but they are rarely enforced. Sadly, corrupt officials often tend to misuse these laws, harassing the genuine needy while ignoring the professionals. The government must take firm meaures to address the critical issue. This can include creating income thresholds, confiscating assets of professional beggars, and reforming taxation policies for those found exploiting charity funds.

Families involved in such activities, like the one in Gujranwala, must face investi- gations for tax evasion, and be punished with heavy fines or imprisonment. Additionally, police officers who allow this practice in exchange for bribes should lose their jobs and face punishment.

People also need to be more cautious. Our well-meaning donations are keeping the social evil alive. Instead of handing over money directly, we should take time to verify if the person truly needs help. Most professional beggars can be identified by asking a few simple questions. It is time to act as responsible citizens and demand stricter enforcement of laws. Together, we can discourage this scam and make our society more just and fair.

Prof. M. Fayyaz
Charsadda

Published in Dawn, December 13th, 2024

Opinion

Editorial

Al Qadir ruling
Updated 18 Jan, 2025

Al Qadir ruling

One wonders whether the case is as closed as PTI’s critics would have one believe.
Atlantic tragedy
18 Jan, 2025

Atlantic tragedy

AS reports emerge of another migrant boat sinking — this time in the Atlantic off the coast of Western Sahara — ...
Cheap promises?
18 Jan, 2025

Cheap promises?

TALK is cheap. Can electricity also be? The government has recently announced that Pakistan will benefit from the...
Never again
Updated 17 Jan, 2025

Never again

The Gaza genocide has also revealed the utter helplessness of the Palestinian Authority in projecting Palestine’s case globally.
World Bank loan
17 Jan, 2025

World Bank loan

THAT the World Bank will give $20bn to Pakistan in the next 10 years to address some of the country’s most acute...
India’s dangerous game
17 Jan, 2025

India’s dangerous game

THE latest inflammatory remarks by India’s military brass about Pakistan mark a troubling departure from the...