Racist talk

Published January 15, 2025

WHEN racist tropes are amplified by the expansive reach of social media, the affected communities face real-world danger. That is why it is important to address the narrative — being pushed principally by X owner Elon Musk — seeking to vilify British-Pakistanis over the UK’s past child grooming scandal. The crimes of those involved are indefensible and they must face justice; however, this does not mean that dark forces should be allowed to exploit this tragedy, and malign whole communities. In this respect, the Foreign Office has condemned the “racist and Islamophobic” narratives in the UK, while calling out efforts to demonise the “large and diverse” British-Pakistani community. Though the crimes in question date back to 2008, Mr Musk has of recent chosen to dredge up the Rochdale case and go after ‘Pakistani grooming gangs’, while accusing Labour — including the current British prime minister — of covering up the matter as British-Pakistanis form a major voting bloc for the party. The Conservatives and the British far right, have jumped onto the Musk bandwagon, bringing the grooming issue back into the spotlight.

Of course, in the face of spin doctoring, facts are of little value. While most of the perpetrators of the Rochdale atrocity were indeed British-Pakistanis, a 2020 UK Home Office study said that “group-based child sexual exploitation offenders are most commonly white”. Yet those looking to target Muslims or Pakistanis cherry-pick information, or manufacture alternative ‘facts’ to suit their dangerous agendas. For example, after three little girls were brutally murdered in the British town of Southport, disinformation was spread that the perpetrator was a Muslim migrant. Though patently false, this rumour led to intense anti-Muslim rioting. According to one researcher, posts suggesting that the crime was carried out by a Muslim or a migrant received 27m impressions. It is particularly dangerous when a man with obscene wealth — and running one of the world’s largest social media firms — chooses to amplify hateful and divisive rhetoric. It should be remembered that similar propaganda was used by the Nazis to justify the extermination of Europe’s Jews. Therefore, progressive forces must counter this hateful campaign of the far right and big tech with solidarity and the truth. Those involved in wrongdoing should face the law regardless of their ethnic origin or religious background. But whole communities cannot be vilified.

Published in Dawn, January 15th, 2025

Opinion

Editorial

Errant ECP
Updated 22 Jan, 2025

Errant ECP

THE ECP has once again earned a detailed reprimand from the Supreme Court. That it still refuses to correct course is ominous
Fast-tracking M6
Updated 22 Jan, 2025

Fast-tracking M6

GRAND infrastructure projects in Pakistan often progress at the pace of a bullock cart rather than a bullet train....
Gwadar airport
Updated 22 Jan, 2025

Gwadar airport

THE air connectivity established by the inauguration of PIA flights between Karachi and Gwadar is a major step...
Trump 2.0
Updated 21 Jan, 2025

Trump 2.0

Few have forgotten how disruptive Trump could be as president. There has been little indication that his 2nd term will be any different.
GB’s status
21 Jan, 2025

GB’s status

THE demand raised by the people of Gilgit-Baltistan for constitutional clarity and provisional provincial status is...
Panda bond
Updated 21 Jan, 2025

Panda bond

ISLAMABAD’S plans to raise $200m from China’s capital markets through the inaugural issue of a Panda bond this...