NEW DELHI, Feb 4: New Delhi’s hurry to clinch a controversial nuclear deal with the United States despite its unpopularity in the Indian parliament was politically divisive and there would be no harm done if it were abandoned, two former foreign ministers said on Monday.

Rejecting Foreign Minister Pranab Mukherjee’s claim on Sunday that India would be “isolated” if the Indo-US nuclear agreement falls through, former ministers Kunwar Natwar Singh and Digvijay Singh described it as a “spectacularly divisive deal”.

“It is the UPA that is isolated on the nuclear deal. The UPA government was isolated in both houses of parliament,” Mr Natwar Singh, a suspended Congress leader, said in a joint statement with another former minister Digvijay Singh.

“To go ahead with this spectacularly divisive deal will be tantamount to disregarding parliament,” they said. Mr Mukherjee had said in Kolkata that “if the agreement is not through, we could have to face isolation and possibly isolation in sanction too.”

Monday’s joint statement said India was not isolated when it did not sign the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) in 1968. “We were not isolated when we exploded a nuclear device in 1974.

“We were not isolated when we did not sign the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty, not too long ago. We were not isolated in 1998 when we exploded a number of nuclear bombs,” they contended.

Opinion

Editorial

What now?
20 Sep, 2024

What now?

Govt's actions could turn the reserved seats verdict into a major clash between institutions. It is a risky and unfortunate escalation.
IHK election farce
20 Sep, 2024

IHK election farce

WHILE India will be keen to trumpet the holding of elections in held Kashmir as a return to ‘normalcy’, things...
Donating organs
20 Sep, 2024

Donating organs

CERTAIN philanthropic practices require a more scientific temperament than ours to flourish. Deceased organ donation...
Lingering concerns
19 Sep, 2024

Lingering concerns

Embarrassed after failing to muster numbers during the high-stakes drama that played out all weekend, the govt will need time to regroup.
Pager explosions
Updated 19 Sep, 2024

Pager explosions

This dangerous brinkmanship is likely to drag the region — and the global economy — into a vortex of violence and instability.
Losing to China
19 Sep, 2024

Losing to China

AT a time when they should have stepped up, a sense of complacency seemed to have descended on the Pakistan hockey...