New controversy in India over N-deal

Published September 4, 2008

NEW DELHI, Sept 3: India’s government was on Wednesday hit by a fresh storm over its nuclear energy deal with the United States following reports of new US stipulations.

The agreement, which is entering the final stages of approval, offers India access to western technology and cheap atomic energy on the condition that it allows UN inspections of some of its nuclear facilities.

But Indian media reported that a 26-page US State Department letter states that Washington also reserves the right to cut off nuclear fuel supplies to India if it carries out new nuclear weapons tests.

Foreign ministry spokesman Navtej Sarna played down the revelation, saying India was anyway sticking with a self-imposed nuclear test ban.

“We have a unilateral moratorium and this is reflected in the Indo-US joint statement of July 18, 2005,” he said.

Washington’s ambassador to New Delhi also tried to downplay the row, which has erupted on the eve of a meeting of the 45-nation Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG) which must give its unanimous thumbs up for the landmark deal to be implemented.

“This letter contains no new conditions and there is no data in this letter which has not already been shared in an open and transparent way with members of the Congress and with the Indian government,” David Mulford said.

Still, the reports triggered a storm among Indian critics of the deal, who have long argued that the pact would cripple the country’s strategic programme.

“It’s a complete sell-out by the Congress party government,” said Ravi Shankar Prasad, spokesman for the main opposition Bharatiya Janata Party.—AFP

Opinion

Editorial

Successful summit
Updated 17 Oct, 2024

Successful summit

Platforms like SCO present an opportunity for states to set aside narrow differences.
Failed tax target
17 Oct, 2024

Failed tax target

THE government’s plan to document retailers for tax purposes through its ‘voluntary’ Tajir Dost Scheme appears...
More questions
17 Oct, 2024

More questions

THE alleged rape of a student at a private college in Lahore has sparked confusion, social media campaigns, ...
Two steps back
Updated 16 Oct, 2024

Two steps back

Instead of treating polio as a stand-alone emergency, it should be incorporated into a broader public health strategy.
Defunding varsities
16 Oct, 2024

Defunding varsities

IF a plan — apparently conjured up by foreign lenders — to defund public varsities goes ahead, tens of thousands...
Protecting children
16 Oct, 2024

Protecting children

THIS country’s children make the news for unfortunate reasons. At the core of their plight is the state’s...