Russia angry at US-India arms talks

Published December 1, 2004

NEW DELHI, Nov 30: Russia tersely told India on Tuesday that it would no longer transfer any high technology defence system to New Delhi without a pact to protect intellectual property rights (IPR) , and said India's bid to buy American Patriot anti-missile system would not work on Russian-supplied platforms.

Press Trust of India quoted Russian Defence Minister Sergei Ivanov as saying in Moscow that it was not going to move further in sharing sophisticated military technologies with India without the IPR pact.

"In our military-technical cooperation we have come to a stage when, without signing of the agreement on the protection of Intellectual Property Rights (IPR), we cannot look ahead," Mr Ivanov said here ahead of his trip to New Delhi to prepare the ground work for President Vladimir Putin's three-day visit beginning this week.

During his stay in New Delhi, Mr Ivanov will co-chair the fourth session of the Indo-Russian inter-governmental commission on military cooperation along with his Indian counterpart Pranab Mukherjee to finalize defence agenda for talks between Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and Putin on Dec 3.

On reports about India's plans to assess the US Patriot ABM system, he said Russia has already demonstrated its S-300 system to Indian experts at several occasions. He expressed doubt whether Patriot missiles could be amalgamated into the integrated air defence system modelled by Russia for India, PTI said.

"To do this we have to get access to the source codes of Patriot missiles, which the US will not give. We also will not give our source codes if India goes ahead with the American system of control," Mr Ivanov said.

He indicated that the absence of IPR protection agreement has become an 'obstacle' in the development of defence cooperation involving the cutting-edge technologies. "It has become something of an obstacle if we think of future, we can fulfil our previous obligations without this, but we cannot move ahead in high technology cooperation," Mr Ivanov said.

He noted that Russia had submitted the draft of the agreement to India two years ago, but the Indian side had not even given its suggestions or proposals on it. "We will not give away such high technology without signing IPR agreement, for free.

India is a priority and strategic partner of Russia. It was also a strategic partner of Soviet Union, which used to give many things for free, but things have changed. Russia is a different country and there is a need for taking cognizance of this reality," Mr Ivanov said.

He also expressed Russia's displeasure over the way New Delhi is treating its strategic partner on the issue of WTO accession and recognition of Russia as a market economy, a step already taken by the European Union, China and the US.

Mr Ivanov said Indo-Russian defence cooperation was moving ahead in accordance with the long-term military technical programme till year 2010. However, like BrahMos cruise missile project, which was not part of this programme, some new projects are in the pipeline for 2005 and in the coming years.

"I cannot share with you at this juncture, what are these projects. At proper time you will come to know," Mr Ivanov said when asked about these projects. Space could become a major, thrust area of military cooperation, PTI said.

"I would rather say the civilian and military cooperation involving space would become a thrust area of bilateral interaction," Mr Ivanov told correspondents from India in Moscow. He said Moscow was not afraid of competition in the Indian arms bazaar from the growing number of new players, including the United States.

Opinion

Editorial

Desperate measures
Updated 27 Dec, 2024

Desperate measures

Sadly in Pakistan, street protests and sit-ins have become the only resort to catch the attention of a callous power elite.
Economic outlook
27 Dec, 2024

Economic outlook

THE post-pandemic years, marked by extreme volatility in the global oil and commodity markets as well as slowing...
Cricket and visas
27 Dec, 2024

Cricket and visas

PAKISTAN has asserted that delay in the announcement of the schedule of next year’s Champions Trophy will not...
Afghan strikes
Updated 26 Dec, 2024

Afghan strikes

The military option has been employed by the govt apparently to signal its unhappiness over the state of affairs with Afghanistan.
Revamping tax policy
26 Dec, 2024

Revamping tax policy

THE tax bureaucracy appears to have convinced the government that it can boost revenues simply by taking harsher...
Betraying women voters
26 Dec, 2024

Betraying women voters

THE ECP’s recent pledge to eliminate the gender gap among voters falls flat in the face of troubling revelations...