LAHORE, July 5: The rule of fitness and suitability has an edge over the principles of seniority and legitimate expectancy insofar as appointments to the Supreme Court are concerned, the court observed in its judgment on five constitutional petitions challenging the elevation of three relatively junior judges of the Lahore High Court.

The Pakistan Bar Council and the Supreme Court Bar Association were among the petitioners and a five-member SC bench, comprising Chief Justice Sheikh Riaz Ahmed and Justices Qazi Mohammad Farooq, Mian Mohammad Ajmal, Syed Deedar Hussain Shah and Abdul Hameed Dogar, dismissed the petitions on April 10 for reasons to be recorded later.

In its 72-page judgment written by the Chief Justice, released by the SC’s Lahore registry on Friday, the court said the petitioners’ contention is misconceived and travels beyond the parameters indicated in the Judges Case and Asad Ali’s Case.

“In our considered view, the scope of the principles of seniority and legitimate expectancy enunciated in those cases is restricted to the appointment of the Chief Justice of a High Court and the Chief Justice of Pakistan and these principles neither apply nor can be extended to the appointment of judges of the Supreme Court. It is nowhere mentioned in those judgments that the principles of seniority and legitimate expectancy shall also apply in the matter of appointment of judges of the Supreme Court. The omission appears to be international and not accidental in view of the line of reasoning in the said judgments.

“There exists no constitutional convention or past practice to appoint the most senior Judge of a High Court as a Judge of the Supreme Court,” the judgment said.

Opinion

Editorial

Kurram atrocity
Updated 22 Nov, 2024

Kurram atrocity

It would be a monumental mistake for the state to continue ignoring the violence in Kurram.
Persistent grip
22 Nov, 2024

Persistent grip

An audit of polio funds at federal and provincial levels is sorely needed, with obstacles hindering eradication efforts targeted.
Green transport
22 Nov, 2024

Green transport

THE government has taken a commendable step by announcing a New Energy Vehicle policy aiming to ensure that by 2030,...
Military option
Updated 21 Nov, 2024

Military option

While restoring peace is essential, addressing Balochistan’s socioeconomic deprivation is equally important.
HIV/AIDS disaster
21 Nov, 2024

HIV/AIDS disaster

A TORTUROUS sense of déjà vu is attached to the latest health fiasco at Multan’s Nishtar Hospital. The largest...
Dubious pardon
21 Nov, 2024

Dubious pardon

IT is disturbing how a crime as grave as custodial death has culminated in an out-of-court ‘settlement’. The...