A net of solar panels in North Waziristan. — Photo by author The official (and unofficial) truth The peace that greeted us in our travel corresponded with the official narrative; that North Waziristan is secure. Yet, when it came to the official line of the agency returning to prosperity, interviews with locals on the ground revealed a more complicated picture.
Chief among the concerns of the local population was the inadequate nature of the rehabilitation works. While some progress had been made in providing essential services, the slow pace of the reconstruction efforts had frustrated and caused tremendous hardship to the locals.
One local, Riaz Khan, complained that life for him could not be considered “normal” when there was no clean water supply for his household and no schools to send his children to.
Another resident, Tasleem Khan, who returned to his home in the Edak area of North Waziristan from an IDP camp in Kohat at the beginning of Ramazan, had similar concerns about the quality of life in his hometown.
“Yes (medical) dispensaries have opened up but there are no emergency facilities. There are no proper surgeons in the area or even any gynecologists who my wife can go see.”
The closest proper medical facilities are in Bannu, but the military only allows people from Miranshah to go to Bannu once a week on Mondays.
In case of an emergency, people are helpless.
This restriction of travel to Bannu not only violates Pakistani citizens’ freedom of movement but also causes tremendous hardship to North Waziristan residents who, in the absence of proper food provisions, household supplies and infrastructure, rely on the markets and facilities in Bannu for all their needs.
With life in North Waziristan still in disarray, it is small wonder that many IDPs are reluctant to return home. Of the 700,000 who left, only 25,000 have returned. One of the many IDPs who have not returned home is Haji Bazeer, previously a Miranshah resident but now living in Peshawar. Bazeer laments that due to the lack of shops and other means of economic sustenance in North Waziristan, he would rather stay in Peshawar.
Locals estimate that before the operation, the bazaars in Mir Ali and Miranshah used to have 3,000 and 5,000 shops respectively. The new Mir Ali bazaar, however, will provide only 120 shops. Even if the 11 new bazaars under construction provide space for 1,100-1,200 shops (which is an optimistic estimate), it would not even remotely compensate for the shops that have been destroyed.
To make matters worse, the places where markets previously existed had their leases cancelled by the civil administration, which means that other than the tiny, new markets, there is no way for traders to engage in legitimate economic activity.
Safiullah Gul Mehsud, a local interviewed for this piece, was genuinely puzzled about what people were expected to do once they did return home.
Light at the end of the tunnel Yet, even the problems being discussed in North Waziristan now come from a certain level of autonomy and opportunity.