An Indian paramilitary trooper guards a polling station during the fifth phase of India's general elections in Kashmir's Shopian district. ─ AFP
The territory continues to be one of the most militarised regions in the world and most residents favour an end to Indian rule. At least 70,000 people have been killed in the conflict in the last three decades.
Militarisation has only increased under Modi, and soldiers now fire pellet guns that routinely maim and blind protesters, and blow up residential homes with explosives during counter-insurgency operations.
Kashmir has been so central to Modi's strongman narrative that even unpopular economic policies have been justified by his government as being necessary for national security.
Modi introduced demonetisation to take 1,000 and 500 rupee notes out of circulation, disrupting business and forcing millions of people to stand in lines to change out their suddenly-worthless bills, as a measure to curb black market money.
The Central Bank later said the measure had mostly injured India's poor.
But Modi and his Cabinet colleagues defended it as a way to stop "terror" funds reaching Kashmiris.
While campaigning, Modi and other BJP leaders have also cast their party as the antithesis of their main opposition, Congress, which ruled India for about half a century starting from independence.
Modi repeatedly accuses Congress of being soft on Pakistan, soft on terror, pandering to Muslims for votes and pampering Kashmiri fighters.
But experts say Congress statecraft had carefully calibrated ways to keep dissent in check through a strict surveillance regime, while maintaining an air of democracy working in IoK.
"Once in power BJP realised that those gaps were actually deliberately placed safety valves allowed to give vent to Kashmiris. With nothing else to show, they are going after these safety valves one after another," said Kumar, the historian.
"They've little time to bother for the long-term consequences of their muscular approach on Kashmir as long as it helps them consolidate power nationally in (the) short term," he said.