Social media users were sharing a video of Baloch activist Dr Mahrang Baloch being manhandled by police on Thursday, claiming she was arrested. However, the video is an old one from June 2020.

The Baloch Yakjehti Committee (BYC) kicked off a protest in Gwadar on July 28, following arrests and deadly clashes with security forces, against alleged human rights violations and exploitation of the province’s resources.

Prominent leaders were arrested in the ensuing days, prompting widespread protests. The BYC signed an agreement with the provincial government today and agreed to end the protest following the fulfilment of its demands, including the release of all those arrested.

A video was shared on Thursday by an X user, who appeared to be a PTI supporter based on his past posts, showing Dr Mahrang being manhandled by police with the caption, “The scene of the arrest of Mahrang Baloch. What does this state actually want?”

The post was seen by more than 167,000 people.

The same video was shared by another account on X with the caption, “Mahrang Baloch has been arrested.”

This post was seen by more than 50,000 people.

The same video with a similar caption was shared by other X users as well as can be seen here and here.

A fact check was initiated to determine the veracity of the claim due to its virality and because it came amid the ongoing protest movement in Balochistan for its rights, of which Dr Mahrang is one of the lead organisers.

A reverse image search conducted using screenshots led to an X post by Dr Mahrang on June 24, 2020.

The Baloch activist shared the same video with the hashtags “restore internet in Balochistan” and “say no to online classes” while the caption for the post said: “It has always been the attitude of the Pakistani state that peaceful strugglers have been labelled evildoers and terrorists, and the police SHO is calling the students evildoers. But we will continue to struggle.”

A keyword search for “Balochistan”, “Mahrang arrest” and “online classes” to determine if any news outlet reported the incident yielded a news story published by The Express Tribune on June 25, 2020, with the headline, “Protesting students arrested for demanding internet facilities in Quetta”.

According to the report, the Balochistan police arrested over two dozen students, including Dr Mahrang, during a protest in Quetta demanding internet access for online classes.

Click to see more

The demonstration, organised by the Baloch Students Alliance, opposed the province’s move to conduct online classes amid poor internet facilities. The arrests occurred under Section 144, which banned gatherings due to Covid-19 restrictions in place at the time.

A Balochistan-based news outlet also reported the same news in an article dated June 28, 2020.

Furthermore, neither the BYC nor Dr Mahrang’s social media pages posted any update or post on August 1 or 2 about her alleged arrest or any such development.

Therefore, the fact check determined that the claim regarding a video showing Dr Mahrang Baloch’s arrest was misleading.

The video circulating was an old one from June 2020 when she was arrested by the Balochistan police while protesting and demanding internet access for online classes during Covid-19.

Resharing the old video without mentioning its original context or details such as its original date has the potential to mislead the public into thinking that the arrest is amid the current tense situation which can further inflame and aggravate the situation by inciting people towards violence based on misunderstanding.

This fact check was originally published by iVerify Pakistan — a project of CEJ and UNDP.