Jinnah’s vision

Published December 25, 2015

The frequent projection of Mohammad Ali Jinnah’s Aug 11 address to the Constituent Assembly creates an impression that this is the Quaid’s only speech that gives us his vision of Pakistan.

On the contrary, throughout his political career, Jinnah made it repeatedly clear that he visualised Pakistan as a democracy guaranteeing fundamental rights to all its citizens irrespective of their beliefs.

As he told a rally in Chittagong in March 1948, the denial of these rights in a united India was one of the reasons why South Asian Muslims had struggled to create a country of their own.

In February 1948, in a radio broadcast, the Quaid declared that Pakistan was not going to be “a theocratic state — to be ruled by priests with a divine mission”. Non-Muslim minorities, he said, would “enjoy the same rights and privileges as any other citizens and will play their rightful part in the affairs of Pakistan”.

It is difficult to be precise if we try to determine exactly when retrogressive forces found an environment conducive to their growth. But the consequences of Pakistan’s involvement in the US-led ‘jihad’ against the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan unleashed forces that have over the last 36 years traumatised the nation and torn asunder the very fabric of society.

While terrorism and armed rebellion are the visible manifestation of this reactionary radicalism, the more insidious form of it is to be found in the silent spread of the virus of mediaeval intolerance at all levels of society — even at places where it shouldn’t be, for instance, institutes of higher learning, cultural organisations and the arts.

The harm done to education is a subject unto itself, but what is happening is the consequences of what Jinnah had expressly warned students against in a speech at Dacca in March 1948: “You will be making the greatest mistake if you allow yourself to be exploited by one political party or another ... Your main occupation should be ... to devote your attention to your studies.”

In contrast, the standards of education have gone down because the academia and student bodies are under the influence of religiously inspired hard-line elements whose brainwashing techniques are no more confined to madressahs.

Is there a silver lining in the cloud? It is hard to see one. Those at the helm are seen as largely corrupt and lack the fundamental attributes of leadership.

There is no statesman in sight who could have the courage to take on the extremists and tell the truth — that behind the façade of fiery rhetoric and street power, bigoted minds do not have with them the blueprint of a scientifically advanced and prosperous nation that conforms to Jinnah’s vision of a democratic state where people could “breathe as free men and which we could develop according to our lights and culture and where principles of Islamic social justice could find free play”.

Published in Dawn, December 25th, 2015

Opinion

Editorial

New CEC?
Updated 29 Mar, 2025

New CEC?

The ruling parties should avoid getting involved in another controversy around the ECP.
Balochistan violence
Updated 29 Mar, 2025

Balochistan violence

How long can the state allow this unending cycle of violence in Balochistan to continue?
Turkiye protests
29 Mar, 2025

Turkiye protests

DAILY protests have continued in Turkiye since the arrest of Istanbul Mayor Ekrem Imamoglu on March 19. While the...
Fear tactics
Updated 28 Mar, 2025

Fear tactics

Under Peca amendments, regime has legal cover to bully and harass working journalists for taking adversarial positions.
Hints of hope
28 Mar, 2025

Hints of hope

PAKISTAN’S economic growth has slowed in the second quarter of the ongoing fiscal year from a year ago as the...
Capacity issues
Updated 28 Mar, 2025

Capacity issues

Development of railway capacity to facilitate ordinary travellers does not seem to have been a priority for Pakistan.