‘Inmates with mental disorders increasing’

Published April 28, 2019
There are approximately 4,688 prisoners on death row in Pakistan, of which 188 mentally ill are in Punjab alone. — AFP/File
There are approximately 4,688 prisoners on death row in Pakistan, of which 188 mentally ill are in Punjab alone. — AFP/File

ISLAMABAD: Presence of people with mental disorders in detention facilities is steadily increasing in Pakistan.

According to authorities, there are approximately 4,688 prisoners on death row in Pakistan, of which 188 mentally ill are in Punjab alone.

This was stated by Executive Director, Justice Project Pakistan, Sarah Belal while speaking at a consultative dialogue on ‘Mental Healthcare in Detention Facilities’.

The event was organised by the National Academy for Prison Administration in collaboration with International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) and Justice Project Pakistan at a local hotel.

Ms Belal said: “Mentally ill people are not responsible for their crimes because the intention element is not always there or at least not to the same extent.”

Consultant psychiatrist Asma Humayun in her presentation said it was extremely important to develop a mechanism to identify people who were at risk of mental disorders or were already mentally unwell when they are entering detention facilities.

“Many prisoners might not have mental disorders but instead might be suffering from learning disabilities. A majority of prisoners suffering from common mental disorders can be treated by non-specialists,” she said.

A panel comprising IG prisons and jail superintendents also discussed the challenges of managing detainees with mental disorders, gaps in existing mental healthcare in prisons, legal deliberations on issues of mental incapacity, limitations of forensic assessments and reports, and implementation of mental health legislation.

They said there were serious medical and ethical concerns for detainees with mental disorders.

The issue also creates a significant burden on an over-crowded and under-resourced correctional system.

The association between mentally ill detainees and prison environment is a complex one where people with mental disorders are vulnerable as both, victims and violators.

The aim of the conference was to assess mental healthcare needs in prison and identify gaps in existing services.

Published in Dawn, April 28th, 2019

Opinion

Editorial

Improved outlook
Updated 16 Apr, 2025

Improved outlook

Remittances have proved to be most crucial lifeline for Pakistan in recent years.
Water dispute
16 Apr, 2025

Water dispute

WITH a long, hot summer looming ahead, the last thing the country needs is two provinces fighting over water. Yet,...
A positive start
16 Apr, 2025

A positive start

FROM American threats of bombing Iran, things have taken a more positive turn as President Donald Trump’s emissary...
Iran slayings
Updated 15 Apr, 2025

Iran slayings

State authorities on both sides must investigate latest attack, while Tehran should locate perpetrators and bring them to justice.
AI in the courts
15 Apr, 2025

AI in the courts

SUPREME Court Justices Aqeel Ahmed Abbasi and Mansoor Ali Shah’s judgment on the use of AI in the judiciary landed...
Refusal crisis
15 Apr, 2025

Refusal crisis

PAKISTAN’S polio case count, with 105 days of the year lapsed so far, is in the single digits. But the question ...